menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Illusion Of The Open Commons And Chokepoints In The Indian Ocean – OpEd

6 0
21.07.2026

The Indian Ocean is a “bounded ocean” with nine critical chokepoints (Hormuz, Bab-el-Mandeb, Malacca, etc.) controlling over 60% of global maritime trade and 80% of oil trade, making disruptions (as seen in the 2026 Hormuz crisis) a structural vulnerability.

India is actively building a “geometry of collaboration” across the maritime arc, strengthening partnerships with Mauritius/Seychelles (western rim), Indonesia (Malacca/Sunda gateways), Australia (southern approaches), and New Zealand (South Pacific), while institutionalizing good order through the Indian Navy’s 2026 Maritime Security Strategy.

The Indian Navy is transitioning from a “Net Security Provider” to a “Preferred Security Partner” via Mission-Based Deployments, enhanced Maritime Domain Awareness, the MAHASAGAR vision, and force modernization (targeting 200-230 vessels by 2047), positioning India as a key stabilizer for regional prosperity and security.

The global community exists in a state of chronic “sea blindness”, an enduring paradox where the international system takes the global commons for granted until a critical trigger is pulled. On 28th February 2026, that trigger was pulled with unprecedented force as Israeli and United States strikes on Iran effectively shuttered the Strait of Hormuz. For a world that had briefly forgotten the 2023-2024 Red Sea crisis, the latest naval blockade announced on 20th July 2026 by Yemen’s Iran aligned Houthis against Saudi Arabia, may be a timely warning. Reduction in crude oil shipping and drop in LNG transit through the Gulf has served as a violent awakening to a structural reality. This crisis was not an isolated geopolitical spike; it was a case study in the extreme vulnerability of the Indian Ocean Region (IOR), a “bounded ocean” gated by nine critical chokepoints. While the world’s attention fixed on soaring oil prices, the Indian Navy looked upon a crisis it had forecasted for decades. To secure the vision of Viksit Bharat 2047, India has transitioned from a reactive posture to a sophisticated grand strategy, institutionalising “good order” across these nine gates through a calibrated blend of maritime diplomacy, doctrinal evolution, and operational readiness 

A Geography of Vulnerability

Unlike the vast, open expanses of the Atlantic or Pacific, the Indian Ocean is geographically defined as a “land-locked” or “walled” ocean, enclosed by the landmasses of Asia, Africa, Australia, and Oceania. This unique geometry dictates that access is possible only through narrow, fragile bottleneck passages. These “Nine Gates”, namely Hormuz, Bab-el-Mandeb, Malacca, Sunda, Lombok, the Mozambique Channel, the Cape of Good Hope, the Suez Canal, and the Ombai-Wetar Straits, control the movement of more than 60% of the world’s maritime trade and roughly 80% of its oil trade.

The 2026 Hormuz crisis demonstrated that rather than being mere episodic, chokepoint risk is structural and permanent. In Hormuz, the world witnessed the intentional closure of a passage as a conflict driven wartime strategy, resulting in damage of more than 40 vessels and the loss of lives of seafarers. This “Hormuz Dilemma” is mirrored in the Bab-el-Mandeb, where non-state actors like the Houthis used inexpensive drone and missile technology to enforce “targeted economic sanctions” on international trade. Meanwhile, the Strait of Malacca faces a tri-fold risk of extreme congestion, piracy, and the “Malacca Dilemma” of great-power competition.

Even the perceived fallbacks are illusions. Rerouting trade around the Cape of Good Hope adds 3000-3500 nautical miles to a........

© Eurasia Review