menu_open
Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver

Herald Scotland

We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

As Glasgow declines, Manchester roars ahead. It doesn't have to be this way

Do you know Cammy Day? Of course you do, because of his resignation as leader of Edinburgh’s council amid allegations of inappropriate messages...

21.12.2024 20

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: Has Labour killed Labour?

Scottish politics was terribly simple in the early days of devolution. It was Labour’s baby more than it was anyone else’s. Tony Blair and Gordon...

14.12.2024 4

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: Could it be that the era of grown-up politics has finally reached us?

Let us first dispense the negatives. There was much in this Scottish Government Budget to concern us. The increased expenditure on the NHS meets...

06.12.2024 10

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: Think smart, Ian Murray: time for a bigger, bolder Scotland Office

Back in July, the words "Anas Sarwar, First Minister" seemed to be etched in stone. Labour had filleted the SNP at the General Election, going from...

29.11.2024 9

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: Lay off Neil Gray: these witch hunting games drag us all down

In October 2002, news broke that the Iron and Steel Trades Confederation had donated £11,000 to the Motherwell and Wishaw constituency office of Jack...

22.11.2024 10

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: Are you ready for the nine-word culture war?

“The net zero madness makes us cold and poor”. Those nine words in a tweet from Jacob Rees-Mogg, former Cabinet Minister and now conservative...

15.11.2024 20

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: Moderates must rise to the challenges of populist nationalism

"‘Don’t let perfection be the enemy of good" is a phrase which feels like it was invented for Bosnia in Herzegovina. I am writing from the eastern...

08.11.2024 9

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: This was a risky Budget at a dangerous time

Of all the gambles taken by Chancellor Rachel Reeves and her Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer at this week’s Budget, the most obvious one...

31.10.2024 5

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: We don’t need to revere the First Minister but let's respect the office

I turned 45 yesterday. This is not a request for comments or letters to the editor to wish me many happy returns, although, reader, you are of course...

25.10.2024 3

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: Why did Starmer not include Scottish regional champions? We haven't any

Alex Salmond’s final tweet, sent just a few hours before his death last Saturday, was quintessential of the man and the politician. Its valedictory...

18.10.2024 6

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: The SNP needs to look forward, not back, and spurn the Greens

It’s all looking a bit 2023 in Scottish politics this week. Headlines across Scotland’s newspapers point to the possibility of the Scottish...

11.10.2024 10

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: Whisper it, but John Swinney is leading a quiet revolution

What happens to a government which has been in office for nearly 20 years? It usually loses. What about a government which has been in office for...

04.10.2024 10

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: Russell Findlay must mind his Ps and cues

Barring some sort of paranormal intervention, this morning we will see Russell Findlay announced as the new leader of the Scottish Conservative and...

27.09.2024 8

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: When the Tories mess up, the Lib Dems have a real opportunity

It is awfully easy not to take the Liberal Democrats seriously. I get it. I get the Lib Dem cringe just as much as the next person. It was very...

21.09.2024 20

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: Gloomy Sir Keir has to do more than say 'we are not the Tories’

Seventy-two days ago, Sir Keir Starmer became Prime Minister. It was, in a sense, a classic change election, much like David Cameron’s in 2010, and...

14.09.2024 20

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: Mayors are the opportunity from this week’s chaos

Helen Keller, the author and activist who became deaf and blind as a baby before going on to write 14 books, said that optimism is the faith that...

06.09.2024 5

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: Cheer up, nationalists... you might still win

Reader, I bear bad news. You thought that, with the General Election out of the way, you could put your politicians back in a box for a while and...

30.08.2024 8

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: The SNP: party with global ambition or a left-wing pressure group?

Early last week, I had the pleasure of visiting Kirkwall as we recorded the second episode of the Holyrood Sources podcast’s Islands Tour. Sitting...

24.08.2024 20

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Does it matter who wins the Scottish Tory leadership race?

Nominations for candidates wanting to stand in the Scottish Tory leadership contest close today. One candidate has already voluntarily dropped out,...

22.08.2024 10

The Spectator

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: The next Scottish leader must expel the Tory party mafia

James Cleverly is an accomplished man. He is, outwardly, a good politician, and those who know him tell me he was a good minister, in charge of his...

16.08.2024 10

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: The gap we need to close is the opportunity gap

Over the last few weeks, since the departure of Joe Biden from this year’s Presidential race and his replacement with Kamala Harris, there has been...

09.08.2024 10

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: Benefits should be for people who need them, not people who want them

HELLE Thorning-Schmidt, the former Prime Minister of Denmark, last month appeared on the Leading version of The Rest is Politics podcast, hosted by...

02.08.2024 10

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: The new Scottish Tory leader’s job is to keep the corpse warm

A period of silence on your part would be welcome. This quote was made famous by Clement Atlee in 1945, but it was used in a message to me just the...

26.07.2024 10

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: The least Swinney and Forbes can do is go down swinging

Ireland is building another motorway. Fifty miles of it, between Cork and Limerick, designed specifically to ensure that infrastructure development...

19.07.2024 9

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: Enhancing Scotland is Starmer's key to enhancing Britain

Most honeymoons are glorious. A week into the new New Labour era, Sir Keir Starmer’s is proving to be so. This is the easiest his time in Downing...

12.07.2024 8

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: Amid the celebrations, there is a SNP-shaped danger for Scottish Labour

A boring election, they said. No. This weekend we can reflect on one of the most impactful and consequential general elections in many of our...

06.07.2024 4

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: The world needs you, Sir Keir - we are in troubled waters

To be read by you, the readers, in the longest running national newspaper in the world is a tremendous honour. However, it must be admitted that in a...

05.07.2024 5

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: Support for independence is solid so why is SNP shedding supporters?

Next week’s general election is, in truth, pretty boring. Or, let me be more specific, it is pretty boring in England. The overarching unknown...

28.06.2024 20

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: It's time to talk about cuts. And yes, than includes the NHS

This is a story about Willie Rennie, in the main. I have always liked Mr Rennie. He is the sort of MSP we should all want at the Scottish Parliament....

21.06.2024 6

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: The Scottish Tories cannot win. So what are they going to do about it?

Margaret Thatcher said that being powerful is like being a lady; if you have to tell people you are, then you aren’t. Lady Thatcher was immensely...

14.06.2024 20

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: Don’t underestimate Nigel Farage's appeal to English voters

In 1986 in Calgary, a provincial political figure named Preston Manning convened a meeting of a handful of key confidants to discuss the political...

07.06.2024 7

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: Relax, Sir Keir, nobody cares about socialism now

“I would describe myself as a socialist”. So said Prime Minister-in-waiting Sir Keir Starmer this week, in answer to what has been one of those...

30.05.2024 6

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Sunak won’t be much help to the Scottish Tories

The first few days of this general election campaign have been characterised by Rishi Sunak’s dismal campaign management. From wet suits and sinking...

26.05.2024 10

The Spectator

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: The Farage factor and why it could yet sink the Scots Tories - forever

In politics, metaphors are very dangerous. At 5.13pm on Wednesday, Prime Minister Rishi Sunak stood in Downing Street, intending to deliver eight...

24.05.2024 30

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: So-called ‘progressive taxation’ has failed - as we all knew it would

Life was looking pretty sweet for Anas Sarwar and the Scottish Labour Party, a month-or-so ago. Ahead of the impending Westminster General...

17.05.2024 20

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: The three pegs on which Swinney should hang his First Minister's hat

Compromise normally makes a good umbrella, but often a poor roof. John Swinney, Scotland’s new First Minister, will hope that the roof will be good...

10.05.2024 30

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: SNP has just made its smartest move in a decade

Smart people do smart things, after all. To be honest, it’s been a while since the SNP made a clever, strategic move. This political party made a...

02.05.2024 30

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: Yousaf must now be bold and bring back Forbes

In the midst of chaos, there is also opportunity. These words were first attributed to the Chinese general Sun Tzu over 2,500 years ago, but they...

26.04.2024 9

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: Scotland needs another parliament - peopled by independents only

The Hate Crime and Public Order (Scotland) Act, passed in 2021 and brought into force earlier this month, will probably stand the test of time. Amidst...

19.04.2024 20

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: Education and the biggest lesson the SNP could learn

A common thread runs through governments which are nearer the end than the start of their time in office. The disconnect between the government and...

12.04.2024 5

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: Here's how Labour could make the decisive breakthrough in Scotland

Nineteen and 41. In respect of this year’s looming General Election, and the number of seats to be won by the SNP, these are wildly different...

05.04.2024 5

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: Two key changes that could save the NHS

It has been over 40 years since former Chancellor Nigel Lawson said that “the NHS is the closest thing the English people have to a religion”. We...

29.03.2024 4

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: Three steps Scotland can take to reach net zero

The problem with target dates is that they come around, sooner or later. This is not to say that targets are bad - they are not, and they can focus...

22.03.2024 4

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: Let's give devolution a chance to succeed

“There shall be a Scottish Parliament’. I like that.” So said Donald Dewar, Scotland’s first First Minister, reading from the Scotland Bill...

15.03.2024 4

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: Ross should stay and regroup rather than resign

When news broke on Tuesday evening that Scottish Tory leader Douglas Ross was on "resignation watch", joined the next day by his colleague and...

07.03.2024 4

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: I'm an ex-Tory communications chief but I want them to lose election

Liz Truss is Britain’s type on paper. The daughter of a university professor father and a mother who was a teacher and nurse, young Elizabeth grew...

01.03.2024 10

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

The Scottish Tories are facing an identity crisis

Why is the only party of the centre-right in Scotland so far away from government? As the Labour Party becomes more sensible under Sir Keir Starmer...

29.02.2024 10

The Spectator

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: Bloated, failing BBC should be made to pay its own way

It’s all change, again, at BBC Scotland. Five years after the launch of The Nine and Seven Days on its new channel, BBC Scotland has put both...

23.02.2024 10

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Andy Maciver: Neil Gray’s problem is both simple and complicated

Who would be Neil Gray? Eight short days ago, Mr Gray was the Scottish Government’s Economy Secretary. Scotland’s economy is not in good shape,...

15.02.2024 20

Herald Scotland

Andy Maciver

Things are looking up for Scottish Labour

Scottish Labour gathers in Glasgow this weekend in both a mental and electoral state few thought achievable just a short few years ago. Having polled...

15.02.2024 7

The Spectator

Andy Maciver

50b33b560d47dbc093d43766adf9302b