It's Time to Confront America's Insurance Monopolies
For decades, Americans have relied on competition in the insurance market to help make healthcare affordable. But in most of the country, competition hardly exists anymore.
That's a primary reason health premiums are growing nearly three times faster than wages, even as patients spend less time with their doctors and face routine delays and denials. In nearly three-quarters of commercial insurance markets, consumers lack meaningful choices. In Medicare Advantage, roughly nine in 10 enrollees live in highly concentrated markets.
Americans are rightly frustrated about paying nearly $30,000 in premiums for family coverage that squeezes patients at almost every turn. Roughly 70 percent support using antitrust enforcement to break up large health insurance companies. And by a 20-1 margin, voters want to block insurers from buying healthcare providers.
Yet while antitrust powers are an important tool — and should be used — they won't restore insurance market competition on their own. To fix our problems, policymakers will also need to unwind the policies that fueled consolidation in the first place.
A few large insurers increasingly control not only health plans but the entire patient care journey — from doctors and pharmacy benefit managers to clinics and hospitals. That has reduced their incentive to improve outcomes and compete on care quality. Instead, every prescription, treatment decision, and coverage........
