menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

The Scorekeeper Fallacy: Rethinking GOP Politics

26 0
06.11.2026

"Our voters are turning out, but they may not vote for us."

Vice President JD Vance says "the smartest data guy I know" gave him that warning before the election. By his account, turnout was "merely OK" in some states and "downright amazing" in others.

Republican ground-game consultants – with permission from the candidates themselves– became the kind of toxic leader I call the Scorekeeper: the leader who mistakes the scoreboard for the game itself. They're hard to spot because they usually mean well, but they are toxic because they degrade the performance of the team overall.

They want results, and a number feels like the shortest path to getting them. Numbers impress donors. But results impress them more. No amount of door knocking was going to make up for what people were paying for groceries or gas, or their belief that the war with Iran was compounding these pain points.

What truly binds voters to a party is a combination of commitments and performance. Incumbents have the privilege and the challenge of their record. Untested politicians can promise the world, and if they’re convincing, they very well might win. That’s why a community organizer like Barack Obama or a sixth-grade English teacher like James Talarico gets elected.

Once you’re in office, you have to deliver. In 2024, the point for voters was not to elect........

© Townhall