Two young fish are swimming along when an older fish passes by and asks, “How’s the water?” The young fish nod politely and swim on. A few moments later, one turns to the other and asks, “What the hell is water?” This is a major hurdle with talking to men about masculinity and how they perceive themselves as men.

Most men do not experience masculinity as an idea. They experience it as an atmosphere. It is the water we learned to swim in before we knew we were swimming. It is in the compliments we received as boys, the insults we feared, the emotions we learned to swallow, the jokes we learned to laugh at, the masks and postures we learned to assume, and the stoicism we learned to mistake for strength.

This is why conversations about masculinity so often begin awkwardly. Ask a man what masculinity means to him, and he may give you a shrug, a joke, or a list of clichés: provider, protector, strong, independent, responsible. None of these words are wrong. All of them are noble. But they often arrive prepackaged, as if pulled from a cultural shelf rather than examined from within a life.

The harder question is not whether a man is masculine. The harder question is whether the masculinity he inherited is helping him become whole.

After speaking with men in one-on-one conversations and small groups- in my personal and professional life for nearly a decade- I have noticed something: men are often more articulate about pressure than they are........

© The Times of Israel (Blogs)