The case against Bennett is not that he is imperfect. It is that when he needed voters, he made clear promises to them he knew he wouldn’t keep.

Naftali Bennett’s political comeback rests on one assumption above all others, that Israeli voters either have short memories or weak standards. There is no other way to explain the audacity of his return. Bennett is not asking the public merely to consider him again. He is asking them to ignore the single most important lesson of his career, that his word is elastic, his promises are expendable, and his political identity changes the moment power requires it. This is not a side issue. It is the center of the Bennett story. Even now, polling shows him still present in the field, he is far from dominant, in February 2026 his list polled at 11 seats while Benjamin Netanyahu led him decisively in suitability for prime minister, 52% to 21%; by April 2026 Bennett’s list was on 10 seats and Netanyahu still held a commanding lead. Bennett may still be in the race, but the public record that shadows him is stronger than his campaign.

The political wound Bennett caused was never difficult to understand. Before the 2021 coalition drama, his commitments were explicit. Bennett said he would not let Yair Lapid become prime minister “in any way, including in a rotation,” and that “Yamina would not sit in a left-wing government”. Those were not vague impressions or campaign-season nuances. They were direct promises made to voters who wanted a guarantee that their vote would not be used to crown Lapid or build a government dependent on the left and Arab parties. Bennett knew exactly what reassurance his electorate needed, and he gave it to them in unmistakable terms.

Then, at the moment of truth, he did the opposite.

The official election results make the scale of that reversal even more severe. In the March 2021 election, Bennett’s Yamina won just 7 seats out of 120. Likud won 30, and Yesh Atid won 17. Bennett did not lead the largest party, the second-largest party, or anything close to a broad popular mandate for the premiership. Yet with only 7 seats, he maneuvered himself into the prime minister’s chair through a........

© The Times of Israel (Blogs)