menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

MBS Needs to Decide: Israel or Turkey and Pakistan. Are We Seeing the Fall of the House of Saud?

116 0
22.10.2026

MBS Needs to Decide: Israel or Turkey and Pakistan. Are We Seeing the Fall of the House of Saud?

The fact that Trump made a comment that Israel has been “very helpful” to Saudi Arabia reveals a strategic dilemma facing Mohammed bin Salman: either to align himself with Israel and thereby offend the Arab and Muslim worlds, or to embrace regional collective security and accept the prospect of a Middle East in which Washington ceases to have the final say.

On October 16th, US President Donald Trump stated that Israel had been “very helpful” to Saudi Arabia and suggested that there was renewed momentum regarding the Abraham Accords. He gave no explanation of the kind of assistance Israel had provided. Yet, the comment did raise an uncomfortable question as to how far Israel’s security capabilities have already been incorporated into the defence of a country which has no diplomatic relations with Israel.

During a discussion involving the Indian defence analyst Pravin Sawhney and the Pakistani host Zulfiqar Ali, a former intelligence officer, the latter quoted Pakistani sources who stated that Israeli military and intelligence personnel had taken part in Saudi operational meetings. He also claimed that MBS had been faced with a choice between Israel and the developing security partnership between Pakistan and Turkey.

The strategic dilemma is certainly real, no matter what the exact details of the claims are. It is possible that the MBS is realising that American protection comes with political conditions, and Trump is clearly playing the Abraham Accord card, while the alternative options carry their own risks and put Israel’s cooperation as a red line. Should the security arrangements in Saudi Arabia break down, the consequences could spread across the entire Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC), endangering regional stability, the energy markets and the other foundations of American influence in West Asia.

The Israeli Option: Security Today but Political Ruin Tomorrow

The appeal of Israel to MBS can be understood as he is cornered internally and externally. Although Saudi Arabia has huge financial resources and advanced Western military equipment, the high cost of weapons does not necessarily mean that they will result in effective combat capabilities, since intelligence integration, operational coordination and missile interception call for expertise which cannot be bought with another defence contract.

As Sawhney has assessed, Israeli troops have assisted in coordinating the Saudi missile-defence operations. If this is true, it would show a degree of practical security cooperation that goes well beyond what is normally seen in the diplomatic normalisation linked to the Abraham Accords.

Trump’s willingness to expand those agreements could thus offer MBS a deal in which he would become more aligned with both Israel and Washington in return for help concerning the immediate threats. But what would Saudi Arabia have to pay as compensation?

The political consequences are huge. For many Arabs and Muslims, normal relations with Israel........

© New Eastern Outlook