menu_open Columnists
Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay

Herald Scotland

We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Online torture gangs - it’s hard to believe such evil exists in Scotland, but it does

Online torture gangs - it’s hard to believe such evil exists in Scotland, but it does

The following article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. Journalists aren’t supposed to ‘look away’. We’re meant to...

yesterday 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Why scarcity in the NHS, housing and jobs is making Britain angrier

Why scarcity in the NHS, housing and jobs is making Britain angrier

It sounds paradoxical - indeed it is paradoxical - but scarcity is ubiquitous today. Nothing is everywhere. At my local supermarket yesterday, shelves...

previous day 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Let's try having an intelligent discussion about mummies in museums

Let's try having an intelligent discussion about mummies in museums

I was a ghoulish child at times. Obsessed with Hammer Horror movies, my bedroom was filled with glow-in-the-dark models of Dracula and Frankenstein;...

27.10.2026 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

SNP must demand powers over broadcasting after death of BBC Scotland channel

SNP must demand powers over broadcasting after death of BBC Scotland channel

The following article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. It’s striking how little folk are talking about the death of BBC...

23.10.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Hysteria over John Swinney’s bus plans has exposed something rotten about Scotland

Hysteria over John Swinney’s bus plans has exposed something rotten about Scotland

There has been some astonishing nonsense spouted over the SNP’s plan to bring buses under public control, not least from members of the industry who...

22.10.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Why aren’t Scottish tourist chiefs cashing in on our incredible folklore heritage?

Why aren’t Scottish tourist chiefs cashing in on our incredible folklore heritage?

You know that habit most of us have where we go on holiday and come back trying to recreate some wonderful experience? It’s usually a recipe,...

21.10.2026 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

The United States is our enemy now. That's why Britain has to join forces with the EU

The United States is our enemy now. That's why Britain has to join forces with the EU

There's a strange fairy tale quality to life in the 2020s. In fairy tales, there’s often a child character who is desperately lost and trying...

20.10.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

The last bond between people and politics has just been broken at Holyrood

The following article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. There's something very peculiar and troubling going on under...

16.10.2026 30

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Why the high street is dying: blame the Goodfellas of private equity

If you want an easy explanation for how private equity works, watch Goodfellas. Martin Scorsese’s gangster movie has a famous scene in which a bunch...

15.10.2026 200

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

SNP, listen up: it's time to talk about Trident. Your policy is a boon for Putin

We should take cheer in intelligent politics when we see it these days. The Scottish and UK governments have a less than noble history of playing...

13.10.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Live-streamed public executions by firing squad: how low can barbarian America go?

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. Where exactly is rock bottom for America? How low can that nation sink?...

09.10.2026 50

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

What French student protests reveal about Britain's broken political system

I find myself full of admiration for the young people of France. Unlike so many protestors here at home – usually middle-aged men in black masks...

08.10.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

The Scottish Endarkenment has dawned in this dumbed-down nation

Today we seem content to just watch as the pillars of society built by our ancestors are torn down and destroyed one by one. The NHS has been...

06.10.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Andy Burnham could blow Scottish indy out of the water - if he does this one thing

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. Scottish independence already exists in a strange quantum state. If you...

02.10.2026 30

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Tracking apps and helicopter parents are creating a generation of snowflakes

In September 1988, I walked out of the front door of my parents’ house and didn’t come back until Christmas Eve. I was off to university. In the...

01.10.2026 30

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Are you ready for movies to go MAGA? Well, you better be because it’s about to happen

Hollywood, and the rest of the American film and TV industry, has never been just about entertainment. It’s a values machine. Domestically, it...

30.09.2026 30

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Shame on them: Drumcree Orangemen desecrate the memory of the dead

It seems the dead are easily forgotten. Men like Michael McGoldrick, Robert Hamill and Frank O’Reilly. Women like Rosemary Nelson. Children like...

29.09.2026 30

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

There is only one option for Sir Ken McCallum after this appalling MI5 scandal

There is a long history of Scots right at the top of Britain’s intelligence services. Meta Ramsay, from Glasgow, who I got to know well before her...

18.09.2026 30

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

James O’Brien’s guilty admission nails the problem of English domination in Scotland

Here's a story about two Englishmen. The first was a very famous journalist, a doyen of the liberal media. During dinner with him, and a flock of...

17.09.2026 30

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Why am I browsing crossbows at midnight? It's all thanks to a terrifying new TV show

Every time my wife and I go shopping these days, I’ll wait until her back is turned and then slip some tins of repellent awfulness into the trolley:...

16.09.2026 40

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Andy Burnham and the great Gen X problem nobody wants to admit

I keep getting struck by disturbing similarities between myself and Andy Burnham. I don’t mean this in a positive way - for either of us. You...

15.09.2026 40

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

We need to know if the BBC deliberately shafted Glasgow over the Commonwealth Games

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. I’m not sure that the BBC could manage to offend and irritate Scots more...

11.09.2026 40

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Prince George at Eton: What kind of parent abandons their child at boarding school?

I suppose I should be grateful to William and Kate Windsor. Not for any grovelling reason. I’m certainly no monarchist. But for knocking the last...

10.09.2026 30

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

With one stupid picture, Sturgeon has blown her feminist credentials to smithereens

It’s the 1950s obedient housewife vibe that really shocks when you see the picture. It demands a double-take. There she is, Nicola Sturgeon, playing...

08.09.2026 40

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

BBC Scotland is dead, it doesn’t have the wit to get into its coffin and shut the lid

Soap opera symbolism is always clunky. When scriptwriters want to add some subtext, they don’t tend to follow the Tennessee Williams’s formula for...

05.09.2026 40

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Champagne, oysters and billionaire bucks: how can anyone vote for Farage’s party?

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. Here's the publicly curated image: Nigel Farage, man of the people,...

04.09.2026 40

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Scotland needs more stories like the Great Bernera café dog row and Skye ferry laird

When I was a kid, I loved the comic 2000 AD. I remember buying the first edition, which I still have and which is apparently worth a fortune, in 1977....

03.09.2026 30

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

SNP talk of pact with Farage in return for indyref2 should revolt every Yes voter

The victims of politics were once merely confined to the likes of you and I – ordinary voters who had their lives maimed and afflicted by the...

01.09.2026 40

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

SNP in uproar as members claim Swinney just doesn’t care about independence

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. Most of the Yes movement has long dismissed claims that the SNP isn’t...

28.08.2026 40

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Britain should create its own Facebook and Instagram, not depend on US firms

It's difficult, if not impossible, to feel anything other than revulsion, and frankly hate, towards American social media giants. The equivalence...

27.08.2026 40

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Dry your eyes, Stephen Flynn. Why shouldn't the media scrutinise SNP spending?

It didn’t take me long as a young journalist to realise all was not well with my profession. I became a reporter long ago, in 1991. Margaret...

25.08.2026 50

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

SNP can either cosplay as social justice warriors or fight homelessness with Burnham

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. I still recall the first time I saw someone sleeping rough. It was during a...

21.08.2026 40

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Flogging this Scottish treasure to an overseas buyer is nothing but barbarism

THERE’S a distinct whiff of barbarism in the way Scotland’s elected officials in the Highlands are behaving today. The matter centres on the bust...

21.08.2026 50

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Why everything feels broken: Three books that make sense of modern chaos

The tragedy of my generation is that we were raised in a period when news and analysis moved slowly enough for even those who didn’t stay across...

20.08.2026 50

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Jason Arday case shows the persecution of minorities has reached bloodthirsty levels

It should revolt the entire nation that a Scottish academic is scared to speak about her work because of the colour of her skin. I met with Melanie...

18.08.2026 60

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Trapped between cowards and cranks, the SNP has left the indy movement to unravel

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. All eyes are currently on the strange, whacky and cowardly behaviour of...

14.08.2026 50

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Should I ride the fat-jag pony or embrace my fate as a middle-aged chubster?

I had a moment of intense middle-aged horror just before I went on my summer holiday. I was packing my suitcase and reached for my lovely...

13.08.2026 40

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

This is great: I am so enjoying Nicola Sturgeon’s ‘couldn’t GAF’ attitude right now

Scotland seems divided into three distinct groups. There’s the 10% who obsessively hate Nicola Sturgeon. Hate is a strong word, but these folk...

10.08.2026 50

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

The Scottish legends at the heart of Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey

First, a brief review. Christopher Nolan’s The Odyssey is magnificent. I’ve a few gripes, which drop it from an A to a mere A, but none are to do...

25.07.2026 50

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Andy Burnham has just made a huge mistake over independence

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. We were so close, yet so far. So close you could almost taste it - like poor...

24.07.2026 40

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Drill, baby, drill: We’re like Nero fiddling while Arthur’s Seat burns

I sometimes wonder whether much of the rage which swirls around these days is down to a collective sense of shame at our own suicidal stupidity as a...

23.07.2026 40

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

If Burnham lives up to his promise, he kills the SNP and indy stone dead

I detest the type of person who is my age – mid-50s – and forever sneering at young folk. They forget we were once young – albeit in the last...

21.07.2026 40

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Finally, there’s a way to put the Sturgeon-Salmond-Murrell scandals to bed

As matters stand today, Nicola Sturgeon will never get out from under the scandals that are plaguing her. Most political leaders leave office carrying...

17.07.2026 50

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

How a £37 million T-Rex is the last gobble of the monster rich

It's impossible to be certain about how our ancestors lived in the ancient past. There’s no recorded history, after all. However, scholars are...

16.07.2026 50

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Stop calling Farage ‘daddy’, you weirdos, you’re creeping everyone out

In Northern Ireland, where I’m from, there’s a weird, disturbing cultural quirk found in a minority of folk which, I’m afraid, gives me the...

14.07.2026 60

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

New Lowe: Debasing Dunblane on Rogan show symbolises collapse of politics and media

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. Only the psychopathic or sadistic could remain untroubled by the depths to...

10.07.2026 50

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Why some Scottish traditions need to die - get over it

I’ve a healthy distrust of tradition. Ironically, my suspicion was bred deep, from my formative years. It’s hard to respect tradition when...

09.07.2026 50

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

From licence fee to subscriptions: what Sky’s £1.6bn ITV deal means for British TV

I imagine one day in the not-so-distant future sitting with my grandchildren on my knee and telling them wild fairy tales so unbelievable that the...

08.07.2026 50

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

How money is killing democracy – now it’s time to take it back

Politics has always been about rich people and their money. Once it was courtiers fashioning themselves into camps to ensure they had the king’s...

06.07.2026 60

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Welcome to Scotland in 2026 - where Blackshirts parade on our city streets

Thomas Weber, professor of history at Aberdeen University, is recognised as one of the world’s leading authorities on Adolf Hitler and the Nazis....

03.07.2026 90

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay