menu_open Columnists
Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay

Herald Scotland

We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Why Scotland's top policy expert says no party offers Scotland what it needs

Why Scotland's top policy expert says no party offers Scotland what it needs

Stephen Boyd heads the influential think tank the Institute for Public Policy Research Scotland. As the election looms, writer-at-large Neil Mackay...

latest 9

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Is the SNP prepared for what happens if it wins next week? Short answer: No

Is the SNP prepared for what happens if it wins next week? Short answer: No

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. You'd be hard pushed to claim this Scottish election has been anything...

previous day 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Us v Them: How capitalism became a living hell for ordinary people

Us v Them: How capitalism became a living hell for ordinary people

I saw an advert for the grandly-named ‘prediction market platform’ Kalshi recently which summed up where we are as a civilisation in 2026. ...

thursday 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Get ready for the ultimate nightmare: Trump backing Scottish independence

Get ready for the ultimate nightmare: Trump backing Scottish independence

The King may have been dispatched to heal the UK-US relationship, but as the Falklands shows, Donald Trump will use anything to wound Britain if he...

28.04.2026 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Grow up, for pity’s sake, of course the SNP will work with Sinn Fein

Grow up, for pity’s sake, of course the SNP will work with Sinn Fein

Unionists have reacted with outrage to John Swinney saying he’ll cooperate with Sinn Fein to boost Scottish independence. Why is anyone surprised,...

24.04.2026 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Oh dear, Gleneagles, I've never heard such unionist drivel about Robert the Bruce

Oh dear, Gleneagles, I've never heard such unionist drivel about Robert the Bruce

I had the pleasure of spending time again with Professor Mary Beard last week, enjoying one of those slow, intelligent conversations which seem so...

22.04.2026 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Want the secret to a happy life? Here it is, and it’s easy and costs you nothing

Our Writer at Large Neil Mackay explains how after a life chasing extreme experiences and emotions, he has learned that it is the simplest things that...

21.04.2026 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Feed the poor or fatten the rich: why John Swinney’s food price cap is morally right

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. We have already entered a new era of ‘Guns or Butter’. Scotland’s own...

17.04.2026 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

When politicians sneer at the ‘lanyard class’, they sneer at our public servants

The words politicians use matters. Today, they’re incapable of speaking without employing the cliched, impenetrable and divisive jargon of the...

16.04.2026 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Thank you, Wes Streeting: every sneer you utter is another vote for the SNP

Labour’s Health Secretary says there will be no independence referendum regardless of what the Scottish people say. Wes Streeting is doing the work...

14.04.2026 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

So now America even controls when we laugh and what we laugh at

The US comedy franchise is just the latest staging post in American cultural and political domination of Britain. We need to get off our knees right...

24.03.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Welcome to Scotland - where the suffering of greyhounds counts more than human beings

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. It's a long-standing staple in first year university philosophy class:...

20.03.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Louis Theroux’s Manosphere made me realise raising a son has never been harder

Boys and young men are being radicalised en masse by a pandemic of brutal online misogyny. Raising a son in such a world has never been harder, our...

19.03.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

The entire Scottish media should back the Greens targeting Elon Musk’s X. Here's why

The Greens want to make social media platforms subject to laws of defamation and libel just like publishers, newspapers and broadcasters. About time,...

17.03.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

'It took a smart English police chief to do what Scotsmen fear: call out Old Firm'

The Chief Constable of Police Scotland did the country a service when she pointed the finger of blame clearly at Rangers and Celtic over disorder,...

13.03.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Timothée Chalamet’s attack on ballet and opera shows the collapse of modern culture

Timothée Chalamet has attacked ballet and opera. How can anyone in the arts behave like this, Neil Mackay asks. He’s a symbol of the collapse of...

12.03.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

At least he's got one thing right: Starmer’s best move is staying out of Trump’s war

The Iran attack has no clear motive or end game, and atrocities are happening. Our Writer at Large asks: how can anyone who says they are a British...

10.03.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Alba is now at the ‘two bald men fighting over a comb’ stage of absurdity

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. For those who like their news weird, unpleasant and with a twist of...

06.03.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

It’s couthy, it’s cringey, embarrassing and twee: that’s Bonnie Scotland on the BBC

With the broadcaster under attack on all sides and accusations flying of falling standards, our Writer at Large Neil Mackay looks at what’s gone...

05.03.2026 60

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Alan Carr’s castle buy in the Borders is a Gilded Age tale for a broken Scotland

Alan Carr has paid £3.5million for a baronial pile in the borders. Neil Mackay says it smacks of the Gilded Age when the rich played and the poor...

05.03.2026 40

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Keir Starmer refuses to even negotiate on indy. That makes me happy

The UK Government says it will not hold talks with the SNP on the issue of what triggers another referendum. Our Writer at Large believes that plays...

03.03.2026 40

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

The Greens proved them all wrong: Starmer, Farage, and the media - the left is back

Our Writer at Large, Neil Mackay, looks at the astonishing success of the Green Party in Manchester and what it means for both UK and Scottish...

27.02.2026 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Our reaction to Nadiya Hussain proves we’ve forgotten what matters

The chef has lost her BBC gig and is now working as a classroom assistant. Why are people laughing at her choice instead of praising her, asks Neil...

26.02.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

What does a colleague calling Anas Sarwar a ‘f**kwit’ say about Scottish Labour?

Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar has been on the receiving end of a brutal and insulting briefing from within his own power base. Here our Writer at...

24.02.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Murrell memo: Why should Swinney know more about this case than the Scottish people?

The Lord Advocate is accused of giving the First Minister advance information on the case involving the SNP’s former chief executive. Our Writer at...

20.02.2026 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Why the row over arming police proves we’ve forgotten how to debate

Last weekend, Neil Mackay reported on calls by the head of the Police Federation for greater access to firearms for officers. The response has been...

19.02.2026 70

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Oh no, save me from an Irishman's nightmare: yet another Irish bar

Glasgow is set to get another chain of Irish bars. As an Irishman, our Writer at Large is not impressed with yet more "cartoonisation" of...

17.02.2026 100

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Is the SNP still actually interested in delivering Scottish independence?

Westminster is imploding, yet there is near radio silence from nationalists when it comes indy, our Writer at Large, Neil Mackay, argues. This article...

13.02.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Epstein scandal forces a reckoning between the people and power

With outrage in the air, the Epstein scandal offers us the chance to rebalance the rotten relationship between the people and power, Neil Mackay...

13.02.2026 80

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

They want £40 billion to rebuild Parliament? Let the damn place rot instead

The Mandelson scandal has revealed a democracy so broken and a politics so toxic that it isn’t worth saving, argues our Writer at Large What could...

10.02.2026 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Whoever is lying about political pressure over QEUH scandal needs to be punished

The truth isn’t being told about political pressure used to speed up the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital's opening. That hurts victim’s...

31.01.2026 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Deacon Blue vs Reform in Scotland: whose side are you on?

Reform’s Scottish leader has offended Deacon Blue by claiming to love their left wing anthem Dignity. Neil Mackay looks at the politics behind this...

30.01.2026 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Unless Nigel Farage finds the guts to stand up to Trump his dream is over

The killing of US citizens by ICE agents puts a spotlight on Reform plans to copy Trump’s mass deportation policy. Our Writer at Large, Neil Mackay...

28.01.2026 30

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Still backing Trump? Well don’t dare call yourself a British patriot

After a week in which the American president trashed Nato and humiliated the UK, our Writer at Large argues that you can’t both support Trump and...

24.01.2026 30

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

I've been in Brooklyn Beckham's position - and he's right to ditch his parents

Neil Mackay reflects on his own painful experience of how easily families fall apart, and why sometimes blood is not thicker than water and leaving is...

24.01.2026 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Easdales buying up Scottish Labour shows why political donations should be banned

Rich donors have corroded our democracy by turning it into their plaything and undermining the interests of the people. It is time for that to end,...

22.01.2026 50

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

This woman is right: we are becoming post-literate screen-fed zombies

The digital world isn’t just reshaping how we tell stories, it’s changing the very nature of the stories we tell - and not in a good way, our...

20.01.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

The BBC has a serious Scotland problem - so why is nobody talking about it?

When it comes to editorial standards and accuracy, the BBC keeps failing over Scotland. Yet the problem is barely discussed in the Scottish media, our...

17.01.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Who do Gen Z think they are? They are most boring generation of all time

There’s a new fashion among young folk. It’s calling the older generation ‘unc’, short for uncle. Neil Mackay , who has fought ageing with all...

16.01.2026 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

SNP should show the world Scotland's values and dump 'deepfake porn site' Twitter

Following the creation of deepfake sexualised images of children and women, remaining on Elon Musk’s X platform guarantees reputational damage,...

14.01.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

What happens if Trump uses independence to set his sights on Scotland?

Many of MAGA’s arguments for annexing Greenland could be used against Scotland. Our Writer at Large says that although the scenario sounds absurd,...

10.01.2026 40

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

America is the new Rome – and Europe must choose between freedom or servitude

There are dark analogies to be drawn from ancient history when it comes to world events today, Neil Mackay warns There's much talk currently that...

09.01.2026 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

What hope is there? I hate what is happening to my children’s generation

Each generation always had it better than the one before - until now. With the world in turmoil, our Writer at Large says it is agonising to see...

06.01.2026 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Tarantino’s right to rant: why harsh criticism still matters in a culture of outrage

Quentin Tarantino has attacked the actor Paul Dano for his role in There Will Be Blood. Folk may not like what he said but he has every right to say...

29.12.2025 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

New ‘Temperance Movement’ is needed to tame the social evil of Big Tech

MI6 issues warnings, great thinkers call for action, and Australia lands the first blow on social media giants. Our Writer at Large says 2026 must be...

20.12.2025 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

We all know the BBC is a mess but we mustn’t let Donald Trump destroy it

The BBC may be bad, but we need to defend it as the alternative would be far, far worse, argues Neil Mackay By any measure, the BBC, particularly...

18.12.2025 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Know what, Robinson? Christ would be on a beach giving tea and blankets to refugees

Extremists like Tommy Robinson are trying to pervert Christianity for their own political ends, disgracing the good that Jesus represented, argues Our...

17.12.2025 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

In Scotland, unlike England, Farage needs to be careful what he wishes for…

Opinion polls show that the rise of Reform has driven support for independence into the majority position in Scotland. It’s a case of blowback, our...

13.12.2025 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Why I won’t set foot in Trump’s America – even for the World Cup

Do events in America outweigh the desire of fans to watch Scotland play? Writer at Large Neil Mackay says he won’t go to the USA as long as Donald...

12.12.2025 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

I had the jag yet still this monster flu tore me apart. Here’s what you need to know

Our Writer at Large was floored by the mutated strain of the flu that is now shutting wards and surging across Scotland. He paints a vivid portrait...

10.12.2025 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay