menu_open Columnists
Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay

Herald Scotland

We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Neil Mackay: Why Harvie quitting could be making of Greens (if they dump Slater too) Patrick Harvie and Lorna Slater should have quit as Green Party co-leaders when the Bute House deal with the SNP collapsed.

Neil Mackay: Why Harvie quitting could be making of Greens (if they dump Slater too) Patrick Harvie and Lorna Slater should have quit as Green Party co-leaders when the Bute House deal with the SNP collapsed.

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. Patrick Harvie and Lorna Slater should have quit as Green Party...

05.04.2025 7

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: The SNP may now be right on Trident, and it's all because of Trump

Neil Mackay: The SNP may now be right on Trident, and it's all because of Trump

My position on nuclear weapons reflects that of many folk, I reckon. Like a mountain switchback road, it has altered course at times over my life. ...

03.04.2025 9

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: Why is the best entertainment from Scotland in years such a secret?

Neil Mackay: Why is the best entertainment from Scotland in years such a secret?

I knew Still Wakes the Deep was special when it blind-sided me with an insulin joke that Kevin Bridges would be proud to have written. For the...

02.04.2025 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: Putin just gave Trump the wink on force against Greenland… be afraid It makes you pine for the good old days of the Cold War. That wasn’t a typo, I meant ‘good old days’, not ‘bad old days’.

Neil Mackay: Putin just gave Trump the wink on force against Greenland… be afraid It makes you pine for the good old days of the Cold War. That wasn’t a typo, I meant ‘good old days’, not ‘bad old days’.

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. It makes you pine for the good old days of the Cold War. That wasn’t a...

29.03.2025 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: The Irn-Bru company shames the very spirit of Scottish enterprise

Neil Mackay: The Irn-Bru company shames the very spirit of Scottish enterprise

I’m beginning to feel like Benjamin the Donkey in Animal Farm. Benjamin lived so long, the world turned him cynical. He knew that whether the pigs...

28.03.2025 4

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: If Starmer keeps going, we'll be the 51st US state and Farage will be PM

Neil Mackay: If Starmer keeps going, we'll be the 51st US state and Farage will be PM

All Prime Ministers have a grand vision for the nation, though they seldom express it clearly. We must intuit their megalomanic mission from the...

26.03.2025 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: For some she’ll always be guilty simply of being Nicola Sturgeon It's a sorry indictment of this country that opponents of Nicola Sturgeon both inside and outside her own party seem incapable of expressing any empathy for what she’s been through over the last few years.

Neil Mackay: For some she’ll always be guilty simply of being Nicola Sturgeon It's a sorry indictment of this country that opponents of Nicola Sturgeon both inside and outside her own party seem incapable of expressing any empathy for what she’s been through over the last few years.

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. It's a sorry indictment of this country that opponents of Nicola...

22.03.2025 5

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: Stupidity is now our biggest growth industry, but can we save the young?

Neil Mackay: Stupidity is now our biggest growth industry, but can we save the young?

Picture yourself in 1995 and your average day. I was 25. Every morning I got the train to work.  Onboard, everyone read newspapers, magazines or...

21.03.2025 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: Starmer has cured me of my Labour nostalgia. Now I know it's indy for me

Occasionally, we find ourselves without the necessary words to express an emotion or idea because the language hasn’t yet been invented. Over the...

19.03.2025 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: Labour is a psychopathic government that’s just as bad as the Tories Unfortunately, I’ve met far too many psychopaths throughout my life. Not more than cops, prison officers or psychiatric staff, but far in excess of the average punter’s brush with the mad and bad.

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. Unfortunately, I’ve met far too many psychopaths throughout my life....

15.03.2025 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: In the end, Nicola Sturgeon didn't do enough that mattered

There's a speech at the end of Christopher Marlowe’s play Doctor Faustus which stands as eulogy for the political careers of so many leaders from...

13.03.2025 4

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: Arthur Miller revival really matters – and Glasgow is its perfect home

If humanity survives this cursed century, I imagine our future ancestors looking back and wondering if it wasn’t the way we entertained ourselves...

11.03.2025 6

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: SNP teeing up for another unnecessary culture war with religious right There's a strange imbalance in Scottish society. As a nation, we’re now predominantly secular: 51.1% said in the 2022 census that they had “no religion”.

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. There's a strange imbalance in Scottish society. As a nation, we’re...

08.03.2025 6

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: My one-man war against the Phantom Fly-tipper of East Ren

Since I hit 50, my life has become a bad British sitcom, featuring me as the halfwit man-child character causing chaos while his family watches in...

07.03.2025 4

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: Morality is on Swinney’s side. Trump should not set foot in Scotland

Hieronymous Bosch was damn good at paintings of humans in hell, yet even he’d have struggled to capture the look of eternal damnation on Marco...

05.03.2025 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: For Swinney, Trump’s Scotland trip will be toughest challenge yet Swinney took a principled, courageous stand – which was also politically savvy. He’s placed himself in direct opposition to the MAGA ideology sweeping the west.

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. For an accurate assessment of Keir Starmer’s White House pilgrimage,...

01.03.2025 4

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: Ban Twitter, rejoin the EU: a 10-point plan for surviving an enemy USA

As the song goes, "all my life, there’s trouble in America". But never trouble like this, and never trouble that’s turned the United States in...

28.02.2025 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: SNP pops champagne as Sarwar self-destructs with Mini-Musk tribute act

We've all been there. That moment when you realise you’re out of your depth professionally and start scrambling around for something – anything...

25.02.2025 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: Hard lessons as Vance humiliates MAGA pet Scottish historian There’s been what’s called ‘an instructive moment’ over on the burning pile of demon excrement once known as Twitter. It featured Scotland’s very own Niall Ferguson, MAGA’s pet historian, being publicly humiliated by JD Vance, the guy-linered US Vice President.

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. There’s been what’s called ‘an instructive moment’ over on the...

22.02.2025 2

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: How Scotland’s disabled folk changed my view on assisted dying

I’ve spent a lot of time lately talking to disabled people and learning about their hopes and fears. It was a chastening experience. A large...

21.02.2025 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: We should wear Vance’s hatred with pride … and get nasty with Trump

Want a good way to get the measure of someone? Look at their enemies. If the goon squad hates them, they’re probably a decent sort. The Scottish...

19.02.2025 5

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: Politics is a sadist realm, a whirlwind should sweep these monsters away Sadism drips through politics at home and abroad, like fat rendering inside a roast. Britain isn’t immune, certainly among our major parties: Labour under Keir Starmer, and the rump monstrosity of the Tories under Kemi Badenoch.

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. Recently, I spotted some graffiti which seemed to sum up what motivates...

15.02.2025 3

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: Make it a must: this stunning Scottish film smashes male stereotypes

There's a moment in Make it to Munich which floods you with happy-sadness, that feeling when you want to smile and cry at the same time, when the...

13.02.2025 4

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: Labour has sold out Scotland. No wonder we're demanding independence

Somewhere in hell there’s a snowball laughing at Anas Sarwar. I’m old enough to remember last summer when everyone was convinced that the SNP...

11.02.2025 7

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: Scots have a real problem with the truth about empire

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. I’ve lost count of the number of historians and educators I’ve...

01.02.2025 40

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: This ancient atrocity explains the horror of the world we’re entering

I’ve been thinking of democracies threatening democracies, of once great nations turning on their allies, of war crimes and liberty perishing, of...

31.01.2025 4

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Relative was executed for murder they didn’t commit. We can't return to death penalty

This is a story I’ve never told. Frankly, it’s been too painfully intimate to recount, and when I was younger the story was the preserve of my...

29.01.2025 30

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: Susan Aitken is gaslighting Glasgow, this city is a filthy pigsty

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. Perhaps I should be thankful for Storm Eowyn, it’s certainly blown...

25.01.2025 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: Nazi salutes and why you should believe the evidence of your own eyes

In the beginning, the drift to authoritarianism is a push-me pull-you exercise. The push side comes in two forms: fear and grooming. Fear doesn’t...

23.01.2025 5

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: Say goodbye to the old order… tomorrow belongs to Trump

In the end, for the end has surely come, it was just a blip. The Liberal Order which governed our lives, the lives of our parents, and the lives of...

21.01.2025 9

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: Want to understand rise of Reform? The reason became clear this week Still in a cosy middle-class bubble wondering at the rise of Reform? Well, the NHS was the one pillar of this nation that gave us all hope and pride. Not anymore. 

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. “I had to change an incontinent, frail patient with dementia in the...

18.01.2025 2

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: Why it's time for the Ulsterisation of Scottish politics

If you listened to the recent edition of Any Questions on Radio Four you’ll have got a flavour of just how contemptible the British public find Elon...

17.01.2025 3

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: The debasement of Scottish education is turning us into an idiocracy

If the legends are true – and pray they’re not, as this legend is so awful it would whiten your hair – then James IV of Scotland was a monster...

15.01.2025 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: ‘Drill, baby, drill’… LA fires are America getting what it voted for Gloating, politically-motivated schadenfreude should never be a response to human tragedy. But that doesn’t mean at times of tragedy that hard truths should be silenced. Indeed, the hardest of times often call for the hardest of truths.

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. Gloating, politically-motivated schadenfreude should never be a response...

11.01.2025 3

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: War on literature heralds the dawn of the New Barbarism

In a world now mostly shorn of truth and authenticity, it is – with the kind of irony only a poet could marshal – to fiction we must turn if we...

10.01.2025 9

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: The Union is on borrowed time: Yes camp must prepare for indy

There are now two inviolable rules of Scottish politics. The primary rule is this: independence support depends upon Westminster failure. The more...

08.01.2025 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: Sarwar should take over Yes movement, he’s doing the SNP’s job for them The Yes movement has been in need of fresh blood for quite some time, so maybe the independence campaign should put Anas Sarwar in charge.

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. The Yes movement has been in need of fresh blood for quite some time, so...

21.12.2024 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: Humiliate them. Ruin them. Stamp on feral Old Firm ultras, hard

I know it’s like asking some folk to moonwalk on a unicycle while doing handstands at an ice rink, but let’s try, just for a moment, to imagine...

20.12.2024 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: Dear religious folk: Sorry, but Santa is just as real as your ‘god'

Some folk believe I hate religion. Not true. Whoever wrote my Wikipedia entry (what a strange job that must be) might be nearer to the mark. They...

18.12.2024 3

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: The stink of Reform is all over the Scottish Tories, they dread Farage It’s quite something to come off as more unpleasant than Kemi Badenoch, but Russell Findlay has managed it. While Badenoch opted for absurdity, Findlay chose cruelty as his means of narcissistic attention-seeking.

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. It’s quite something to come off as more unpleasant than Kemi Badenoch,...

14.12.2024 5

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: The New Dark Age, an era of sex and horror ruled by billionaires

I WAS chopping carrots in desultory fashion the other day when Radio 4’s PM programme gave me what the author William Burrough’s called a ‘naked...

13.12.2024 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: Unionists will never understand the secret of SNP’s success … here it is

Sir Keir Starmer's Christmas present to John Swinney is the pervading sense of hopelessness among the centre ground of Scottish voters. The new...

11.12.2024 4

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: SNP has given up on independence … who will be the torch-bearers now? Got it Neil!

Independence is a project much better suited to opposition than government. It is, after all, quintessentially anti-establishment. That’s its...

06.12.2024 3

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: Wolf Hall is everything that’s wrong with English cultural domination

The gatekeepers of culture in London are wearyingly dull - as pedestrian, derivative and unimaginative as Hollywood executives with their...

05.12.2024 8

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: Scotland’s future: either PM Farage or left-wing populist independence

The future is here and it’s up for grabs. The protocols and ideas which dominated the West from 1945 now exist only in the minds of centrist...

03.12.2024 3

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: Farage is using Trump to stab Britain in the back as he sniffs power It appears that while Nigel Farage knows he won’t become the UK’s ambassador to the court of Donald Trump, he’s quite happy to be MAGA’s voice in Britain.

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. It appears that while Nigel Farage knows he won’t become the UK’s...

29.11.2024 4

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: Things are so bad the SNP should ask Sturgeon back as leader

The SNP is on its way to becoming the Ozymandias party. If you know Percy Shelley’s eponymous poem, you’ll get the similarities. In Ozymandias,...

28.11.2024 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: Calling kids who bought the Band Aid record ‘racist’ is a disgrace

I WANT to say "I get it", which I do. But I also want to say "this is unfair, in fact, it’s even cruel." I understand - partially - why some are...

26.11.2024 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: How much for the Coronation?! Royals aren’t parasites – they’re vampires It’s common to hear those of a republican persuasion refer to the Royal family as ‘parasites’ on the body of Britain. The comparison is apt but not perfect.

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. It’s common to hear those of a republican persuasion refer to the Royal...

22.11.2024 30

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay: John Swinney has made a total ass of himself over Donald Trump

In an age when the cult of youth has never mattered more or swept more away, I remain an unrepentant and unfashionable believer in the wisdom of...

21.11.2024 3

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay