menu_open Columnists
John McLellan

John McLellan

Herald Scotland

We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Call me crazy but here's a wild idea - why don't we build more houses?

Call me crazy but here's a wild idea - why don't we build more houses?

Who could disagree with the Crisis Scotland charity that the deaths of 40 homeless people in a relatively prosperous city like Edinburgh in 2024 was...

07.03.2026 10

Herald Scotland

John Mclellan

SNP shift on grooming inquiry must open the door to wider scrutiny

The SNP U-turn on holding an inquiry into grooming gangs should be followed by accepting that a wider public investigation into child safeguarding is...

28.02.2026 8

Herald Scotland

John Mclellan

Minority Labour rule in Edinburgh hangs by a thread as parties vie for budget deal

Time could be up for Edinburgh’s creaking minority Labour administration as the horse-trading over the City of Edinburgh’s Council’s budget come...

21.02.2026 10

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

Edinburgh clashes expose a standards process struggling to keep pace

More allegations of bad behaviour in the increasingly dysfunctional City of Edinburgh Council once again demonstrate the Ethical Standards system...

14.02.2026 10

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

Cavalcades or clean streets? The real question for Edinburgh’s Tourist Tax

With six months to go before Edinburgh’s Tourist Tax goes live, a bundle of good, bad and indifferent plans have been lined up to spend the expected...

09.02.2026 6

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

Is the public’s right to know really secondary to authorities’ right to save cash?

Whistleblowers’ experience of Edinburgh Council’s handling of freedom of information requests shows just how much reform of the system is needed,...

01.02.2026 7

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

Scotland’s housing emergency deepens amid council wrangles and soaring costs

The housing crisis is real, and although solutions are there to be had, politicians are doing little to solve it except to make it more difficult and...

25.01.2026 10

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

SNP mansion tax leaves nearly 6,000 households in the firing line

Nearly 6,000 Edinburgh households are set to be hit by the SNP’s new mansion tax, another assault on the capital’s aspirational middle classes,...

18.01.2026 10

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

When consequences vanish: Why accountability in Scottish public life is under threat

This week’s events at Holyrood only confirm that a lack of genuine accountability and responsibility for serious mistakes is becoming an accepted...

11.01.2026 9

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

Another week, another Scottish council scandal so why do we accept this moral decay?

Yet another scandal involving Edinburgh’s shamed former council leader Cammy Day should mean Labour’s chaotic administration of the capital city...

04.01.2026 7

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

Great news as council dumps parking charges but the traffic officers will be back

The rejection of more parking restrictions in Edinburgh was the right decision, but might only be a temporary reprieve for residents, writes Herald...

21.12.2025 4

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

Care Inspectorate report exposes deep flaws in Edinburgh’s children’s care system

The Care Inspectorate report into Edinburgh’s troubled residential care system for young people has only scratched the surface of deep-rooted...

14.12.2025 4

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

Edinburgh housing crisis deepens as council plans costly demolitions

Amidst the chaos of Edinburgh’s housing emergency and a soaring population, hundreds of unsellable homes are to be demolished and millions spent on...

07.12.2025 5

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

So is there an 'Edinburgh establishment' child abuse cover-up?

A Scottish Care Inspectorate report into concerns about child protection services in Edinburgh is due next week, but campaigners are not holding their...

30.11.2025 6

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

Failures exposed in council’s £26m spend on unlicensed accommodation

Edinburgh Council’s prolonged illegal use of unlicensed accommodation was an embarrassing failure of leadership and a gift for unscrupulous...

23.11.2025 6

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

Trams extension could transform Edinburgh - but it's not going to happen. Here's why

Unless the Scottish Government changes its attitude to investment in Edinburgh ’s economy and infrastructure, plans to extend the city’s tram...

16.11.2025 6

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

Chancellor’s tax gambit collides with Edinburgh’s housing crisis

As Chancellor Rachel Reeves gets set for a manifesto-busting tax raid , Edinburgh’s Poverty Commission demands more taxpayers’ money to hit an...

09.11.2025 7

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

What is going on as Edinburgh Council stumbles from one farce to another?

The farce at the heart of Edinburgh Council has reached Whitehall proportions with the sacking of one senior councillor and the rehabilitation of...

02.11.2025 8

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

Why are Edinburgh councillors so scared of progress? Take one guess

When even using a basic and commonly available artificial intelligence tool can cause a rumpus, the green agenda will do nothing to improve Edinburgh...

26.10.2025 9

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

The multi-billion price we’re paying for Edinburgh’s bonkers policy on net zero

The observers who warned Edinburgh's net zero policy was unachievable can now say: told you so, says John McLellan If the past, according to author...

19.10.2025 5

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

Time to scrap Scotland’s punitive property tax

Aspirational Scots are being hammered for tax and John Swinney should take Kemi Badenoch’s advice and scrap the punitive Land and Buildings...

12.10.2025 4

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

How Scotland’s Standards Code is failing local democracy

The Standards Commission for Scotland and its Code of Conduct is inconsistent and too easy to weaponise and abuse, says Herald columnist and former...

05.10.2025 9

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

How Edinburgh could learn lessons from Glasgow in terms of tourism

Edinburgh councillors’ hate-hate relationship with tourism threatens to derail the re-establishment of an essential conference marketing agency,...

28.09.2025 6

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

How Edinburgh can get in on the tech revolution

After a slew of major tech announcements this week, new developments in Edinburgh give it a chance to grasp the opportunities big data offers, writes...

21.09.2025 4

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

Edinburgh comes top again in city index but, beware, this praise is exaggerated

Edinburgh scores highly in the new PWC Good Growth for Cities Index and although it doesn’t gloss over problems, it’s a PR stunt which masks SNP...

14.09.2025 7

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

When will SNP learn we all need houses - and transport to get to them

Edinburgh is crying out for new housing developments - and new public transport to get to them, says Herald columnist John McLellan Less than...

07.09.2025 20

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

The daddy of council profligacy and the £4bn bill that could come with it

The potential extension of Edinburgh's trams may come with an extraordinary bill, says John McLennan Like pilgrims wearing a cilice in an act of...

31.08.2025 5

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

Haste ye back Liam and Noel. You’ve nothing to apologise for

Liam’s not happy with Edinburgh. And he’s spot on Liam Gallagher’s opinion of the City of Edinburgh Council was crystal clear. I can’t spell...

17.08.2025 5

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

The AI revolution is not hanging around – we need to make hard choices

As the crowds flock to Festival venues and wonder which toilets they can use in safety, the usual arguments about “over-tourism” will doubtless...

10.08.2025 5

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

'A staggering failure of even the most basic standards'

A good few years ago, a body was found in Niddry Street just off Edinburgh’s High Street, at the service entrance to the Whistle Binkie’s pub, a...

27.07.2025 6

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

Scotland needs a new kind of festival to take on the liberal elite

I’m not sure what qualifications are required for “national treasure” status. Most people would say great age and the absence of controversy,...

20.07.2025 5

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

Visitor levy group will have good intentions but may collide with reality

It’s reassuring the chair of Edinburgh’s new Visitor Levy Advisory Forum, Julie Ashworth, and her new team of 12 advisors are “excited to get to...

14.07.2025 4

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

A vote of no confidence in Labour council is now a real possibility Most of us will have suffered buyer’s remorse at one time or another, from a bad choice in a holiday restaurant to an awful car. The electric thing on our driveway which drains the credit card if it’s recharged anywhere except home being a perfect example.

Most of us will have suffered buyer’s remorse at one time or another, from a bad choice in a holiday restaurant to an awful car. The electric thing...

13.07.2025 4

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

The inside story of the battle for control of Edinburgh

From feather dusters to cocks of Craiglockhart Hill, no-one could blame Edinburgh Lib Dems for being cock-a-hoop after their narrow and unexpected...

06.07.2025 4

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

What row over Edinburgh Tour de France bid shows - and it may not be what you think Edinburgh’s Chief Executive Paul Lawrence apologised for approving the spending to bring the Tour de France to Edinburgh in principle without first seeking formal council committee approval. He has nothing to apologise for, says John McLellan

The Tour de France claims to be the world’s third biggest televised sporting event after the Olympics and the football World Cup, which would make...

29.06.2025 6

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

The verdict on Cammy Day: little in this sordid affair surprised me

Every speaker was heard in respectful silence, but then councillors debating a report into the handling of allegations of sexual harassment against...

22.06.2025 20

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

I'm not sure Edinburgh Council's biggest problem is too many Christmas parties Of all the recommendations from the latest report into whistleblowing culture and safeguarding in the City of Edinburgh Council, it’s doubtful the councillors who ordered it thought it would include a ban on Christmas parties. Before anyone gets the impression that Edinburgh’s City Chambers is awash with Bacchanalian excess, in my five years I never witnessed anything remotely untoward.

Of all the recommendations from the latest report into whistleblowing culture and safeguarding in the City of Edinburgh Council, it’s doubtful the...

15.06.2025 6

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

Edinburgh is held back by its can’t do attitude. It should be more like Glasgow

For a week devoted to putting Edinburgh under the microscope, one of the stand-out stories in The Herald this week was Glasgow’s decision to change...

08.06.2025 10

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

Sir Tom taught us one thing: chin-stroking doesn't build houses - private money does

The applause from Hibernian supporters for Sir Tom Farmer as the hearse carrying his body passed Easter Road stadium this week took me back to the 90s...

01.06.2025 10

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

Surprisingly, telling people road closures are 'for their own good' goes down badly

I’d never been to New York until last month, and like most people visiting for the first time, I was blown away by the experience. Hamilton on...

25.05.2025 9

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

More than 60 transport schemes cancelled in Scottish city in one fell swoop

Most folk enjoy a good old moan about the state of the roads, if enjoy is the right word. Potholes, speed limits, bad junctions and all that sort of...

18.05.2025 8

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

John McLellan: Suspended Cammy Day wants to rejoin the Labour benches in Edinburgh

There are few occasions Edinburgh councillors are in full and genuine agreement, but Thursday’s emotional tributes to the late Val Walker, the...

11.05.2025 7

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

John McLellan: Tear up the council red tape - and let the builders build Well-meaning they may be, but the lesson from the Scottish Government’s emergency rent caps, only lifted a fortnight ago, is they are a disincentive to house builders and investment funds who simply take their business elsewhere. “Rent controls and cost increases have killed the market,” said one senior Edinburgh economic development figure.

It was the local government equivalent of the “I’m Spartacus” moment when Kirk Douglas was about to be nailed up at the end of the 1960 sword...

13.04.2025 10

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

John McLellan: Stop the fighting: Scotland’s two great cities need to pull together The last vehicle to roll out of the Madelvic factory in Granton was before the First World War ended, one of the first casualties in the sorry saga of motor manufacturing in Scotland.

The last vehicle to roll out of the Madelvic factory in Granton was before the First World War ended, one of the first casualties in the sorry saga of...

06.04.2025 20

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

John McLellan: Will we ever find out truth about Edinburgh whistleblowing scandal?

Now Sir Keir Starmer’s bandwagon has been derailed in spectacular fashion by a litany of broken principles and promises, the chances of Anas Sarwar...

30.03.2025 10

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

My message to councillors: dump the virtual signalling and fix our towns and cities

It’s very, very easy to take the mick out of your local councillors, puffed-up panjandrums lording it about their communities like the big bloke in...

23.03.2025 20

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

John McLellan: Impact of tourist tax means Edinburgh needs to rethink arts offering

Edinburgh International Festival-goers are well used to seeing the Dunard Fund credited as one of a small handful of principal sponsors, without which...

16.03.2025 10

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

Plans for major cycle route on prestigious Scottish street may already be dead

For the past two years, Edinburgh residents have been getting used to a ban on cars and buses from George Street at the heart of the New Town, and the...

09.03.2025 10

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

John McLellan: Poor old Princes Street – what on Earth has gone wrong?

Sauchiehall Street is a bomb site, Aberdeen’s Union Street is a wasteland, now three central Edinburgh community councils have united to brand...

02.03.2025 7

Herald Scotland

John McLellan

John McLellan: The lurid green monstrosity that sparked an Edinburgh turf war The Raeburn Place Plook, to give it a good Scottish name, is like a BP garage gorged on steroids. It will never fit in with the leafy surroundings of the beautiful cricket ground, the meandering Water of Leith and the towering grandeur of Saxe Coburg Place

The Stockbridge Slug, the Inverleith Toad, the Zit, call it what you will, not since the Golden Turd adorning the St James Quarter has an Edinburgh...

23.02.2025 10

Herald Scotland

John McLellan