Backstory: What Did the Cockroach Tell News Television? Switch Off, You’re So Yesterday
What does the sudden laying off last week of over 120 employees of a prominent national news television network tell you? That media managements, like their peers in the corporate world, are totally ruthless and completely unconscionable? Right, without a doubt. But it also conveys something else: the disintegration of a model of journalism practiced by the overwhelming majority of news television houses, most markedly since May 2014 when Narendra Modi flew into Delhi on an Adani aircraft to take over the reins of the country.
This journalism of cower-age, hallmarked by unquestioning acquiescence to political authority, has had an impressive run but the excessive verbal ethanol in the fuel is causing its machinery to splutter leading to a sharply declining viewership and ad revenues. It seems the nation no longer wants to know. Or at least no longer wants to know what the government wants it to know through the journalism of cower-age. There are early signs that cracks have developed on the smooth, deceitful surface of this medium and all the uncle-jis and aunty-jis that keep chat shows running won’t be able to put it together again should it fall off the paywall. Shehzad Poonawala, as BJP’s chief content creator on prime time, seems to have been clever enough to discern the impending great crash and has chosen to walk into the sunset before that happened.
Over the last few weeks, a spectre has been haunting television news media, that of the Cockroach Janata Party (CJP). At first it was easy to pretend the disparate, meme-reeling, blattodea-loving gaggle of 20-somethings who had assembled at Jantar Mantar just did not exist. But slowly it became apparent that the CJP was striking a chord with viewers in a way that they themselves, with all their wealth of experience and glamorous anchors, could not achieve. An early comment that appeared in the Wire (‘How the Cockroach Janta Party Transformed From Meme to a Student Movement’, July 9) explained why this was the case: “The Gen Z, self-described as ‘lazy, unemployed, chronically online, possessing an ability to rant professionally’ transformed into fearless critics of a regime that had effectively created a climate of acquiescence and silence.”
The media’s cold-shouldering of the movement did not undermine it. As prize-winning novelist and Wire-commentator Arundhati Roy observed, “Unlike the Anna Hazare movement which had weeks of frenzied, non-stop 24×7 coverage on hundreds of hysterical, corporate owned TV channels, the Cockroach Janata Party has only itself and the internet to bank on” (‘Cockroach Democracy: Unarmed and Dangerous’, July 22).
Television news media, so full of its own self-importance, did not even realise that it was not being missed; that its lack of response to what, after all, was the only news in town – and even country – was leading to a serious dent in its credibility. It also did not perceive that its place as conveyor of news, views and entertainment had temporarily come to be occupied by the meme-makers and the parody purveyors of Jantar Mantar who like magicians had transmogrified into their own reporters, analysts, photographers.
The first signs of life exhibited by television news media during this entire interregnum was 20 days after CJP founder Abhijeet Dipke came to town. It was raining hard that day but that could not stem the tide of young women and men making their way to Jantar Mantar and subsequently to Parliament, demanding the resignation of Union Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan. The cameras of the mainstream television media were not at hand to record the quiet resolve on the part of thousands of youth who converged to the heart of the Capital from across the country, knowing that they were going to make history. Mainstream cameras only rushed in when pitched battles between the police and protestors broke out, creating headlines designed to send shivers down the spine of New India.
Sudhir Chaudhary, editor in chief of DD News, signalled that he was well worth every rupee of his monthly salary Rs 1.25 crore that he drew from the government exchequer. His programme was headlined: ‘Sansad se sirf 100 metre door the updrevi’ (the rowdies were only 100 metres from Parliament). It was a popular script and many other channels jumped in. India Today’s Marya Shakil, using CCTV footage provided by the police, asked ‘How Did Student Protesters Get So Close To Parliament On July 20?’ (July 30).
The Wire carried an interesting assessment of the channel’s coverage from a think tank (‘One Week, 25 Broadcasts, 58,941 Words: How Republic TV........
