Justice Without Vengeance: Why Accountability Must Be Credible to Sustain Peace

This essay is part of the series “Before Reconstruction: The Moral Architecture of Peace,” which examines the psychological, cultural, and moral foundations required for societies to move beyond violence. The series argues that rebuilding institutions alone cannot sustain peace unless the deeper human conditions that make peace possible are restored.

Peace agreements promise stability once violence stops.

But peace rarely survives where people believe harm is denied or accountability is selective.

Durable peace requires justice that is credible without becoming vengeance.

In the previous essay in this series, we explored how shared life transforms fear into responsibility. But responsibility cannot endure unless justice is credible. People must believe that harm is acknowledged, that power is accountable, and that redress does not depend on violence.

Credible justice is one of the final pillars of the moral architecture that sustains peace.

Without it, reconstruction rests on unstable moral ground.

Justice and the Fragile Boundary With Vengeance

Peace cannot endure where justice is absent.

But it cannot endure where justice becomes indistinguishable from vengeance either.

This tension—between accountability and restraint—is one of the most fragile moral conditions in post-conflict societies. Reconstruction efforts often assume justice can be deferred, absorbed into political compromise, or postponed in the name of stability.

In practice, perceived injustice corrodes peace faster than material deprivation.

Communities emerging from violence ask simple but profound questions:

Was what happened to us named honestly?

Are those with power answerable?

Do standards apply consistently—or selectively?

When the answer appears to be no, peace agreements feel hollow. Institutions feel imposed. Authority loses moral credibility. Violence regains narrative power not because people desire it, but because it appears to........

© The Times of Israel (Blogs)