US-Israel war on Iran will bring no fundamental change to the Middle East
For decades, wars in the Middle East have been accompanied by grand predictions. Every major conflict is said to herald a “new Middle East,” redraw the regional map, or permanently alter the balance of power. The ongoing US-Israel confrontation with Iran is no exception. Yet despite the intensity of military operations and the dramatic rhetoric surrounding them, the conflict is unlikely to produce fundamental political change in the region. History offers a useful lesson. The 2003 invasion of Iraq was supposed to create a democratic model for the Arab world. Instead, it unleashed instability, sectarian conflict, and new security challenges. The Arab Spring was expected to transform authoritarian politics across the region, yet many states ultimately reverted to old patterns of governance. Similarly, military pressure on Iran may weaken specific capabilities, but it is unlikely to eliminate the underlying geopolitical realities that have shaped the Middle East for generations. The central reality is that the region’s rivalries are structural rather than personal. The competition between Iran, Israel, and various Arab states is rooted in security concerns, ideological differences, and competing visions of regional order. Military campaigns can alter the balance temporarily, but they rarely resolve the disputes that produced the conflict in the first place. Indeed, evidence suggests that even extensive military operations have not fundamentally altered regional calculations. Analysts continue to observe that Iran retains strategic influence through political networks, regional partnerships, and its ability to shape events beyond its borders. Likewise, Gulf Arab states continue to pursue policies that balance relations with Washington, Tehran, and emerging global powers rather than placing all their bets on a single security arrangement. The war may weaken Iran economically and militarily, but weakening a state is not the same as transforming a region. The Islamic Republic has survived sanctions, diplomatic isolation, covert operations, and previous military confrontations. Even if its capabilities are diminished, the strategic logic driving Iranian behaviour will remain. Regional actors will continue to account for Iran’s presence, just as Iran will continue to seek influence where opportunities exist. Nor is Israel likely to emerge with........
