The Enraging Hypocrisy at the Heart of the Nvidia Scandal
The Enraging Hypocrisy at the Heart of the Nvidia Scandal
Ever since Donald Trump returned to the White House, flanked by a phalanx of supplicating tech billionaires, his administration has emphasized the need to win the A.I. race with China. Trump and his cronies have claimed repeatedly that we can’t constrain A.I. development because America needs to maintain an advantage over its chief geopolitical rival.
Yet the Nvidia scandal has revealed that the administration at best turned a blind eye when a leading American company gave an enormous boost to China’s A.I. industry, all while Trump and his cronies were profiting from it. Though the scandal started with sex — more precisely, the revelation that Jensen Huang, head of the company at the center of the A.I. boom, had an affair with a woman believed to be a Chinese spy — it is really about the administration’s utterly careless attitude toward American security. And it demonstrates the bad faith behind its efforts to shove A.I. down our collective throats.
To understand why Trump’s tech policy has been such a national betrayal, it’s worth going back to Joe Biden’s administration. Ben Buchanan, who served as Biden’s White House special adviser for A.I., told me that America’s A.I. policy under Biden had two, interconnected pillars: slowing China down, and making sure that American A.I. was developed responsibly.
“It was our conviction that it would not be possible, or it would be much harder, to domestically regulate our companies if we were neck and neck with China,” said Buchanan, the author, along with his former colleague Tantum Collins, of an extremely well-timed new book about the global battle for A.I. supremacy, “The Bitter Struggle: Superintelligence, Superpowers, and the Fate of the World.” By denying China the chips that underpin advanced A.I. — most of which are made by Nvidia, and which China cannot yet replicate — the United States would try to maintain some control over the pace of A.I.........
