The political era of the 'safe seat' seat is over
For decades Australian elections were guided by the pendulum – two parties, one swing, and a list of seats ordered by margin that told you what was safe and what was in play at any given election.
A pollster gave you a two-party figure, the pendulum told you which seats fell, and most seats did not move at all.
On November 28 we will witness a drastic change to this electoral custom and Victorians will be the first to showcase it.
In 2022, Victorian Labor won 56 of 88 seats and the campaign was fought in perhaps 15 of them. Although, as I have written before, the warning signs were present at that election and at many others across the country.
That world has gone. The three largest parties in Victoria now sit within nine points of each other and the old question, “which of two parties wins?” has been replaced by a harder one – “which of three finishes second or third?”.
Preference flows now matter in every seat, and they differ from seat to seat so a single number describing the primary vote can no longer describe the result. A range can, and the political machines built for the old question are the last to notice it has changed.
The political machines that have quickly adjusted to this new world will at least not be surprised on the night of November 28.
Our latest Redbridge Victorian poll for the Australian Financial Review has the Coalition on 31, Labor on 23, One Nation on 22, the Greens on 15 and others on 9.
To turn those numbers into seats we use a seat model built on our most recent Victorian survey of more than 7000 Victorians modelled down to an estimate of the vote in each of the 88 districts.
The model takes the statewide poll, moves each district’s vote in step with it and then runs the preference count in that district to find the winner. Run once, it gives a single answer – a Coalition majority of 55 seats.
That single answer is less useful than it looks, because it treats the poll as exact and every seat as settled. So we ran the model thousands of times.
In each run the statewide primaries are moved by the normal error of a poll three weeks out, about two points on each party, and each district’s vote is moved within its own margin of uncertainty so that every run is a plausible election night.
Counting the runs gives two things a pendulum cannot. The first is a range for each party’s seats, where the 90 per cent range is the span that holds the result in nine runs out of 10.
The second is a win probability for each seat, which is simply the share of runs in which a party wins it. When I illustrate a seat reading Liberal 55, One Nation 32, Labor 13, those are not votes. They are chances of winning.
The........
