Inside the unlikely coalition taking on prediction markets
Inside the unlikely coalition taking on prediction markets
A fight over who can regulate prediction markets and whether they constitute gambling is creating strange bedfellows, as the two sides dig in for a protracted legal battle with millions of dollars at stake.
The commercial gaming industry finds itself aligned with tribal gaming and unions, as they argue states and tribes should be able to enforce their gambling laws against prediction markets.
It’s an unusual coalition, bringing together organizations that haven’t always seen eye to eye in the past. But they’re increasingly showing a unified front, as they face off against the platforms, which have the backing of the Trump administration.
“To see us sitting on the same side of the table advocating together is something I would have never thought would have happened,” James Siva, chairman of the California Nations Indian Gaming Association (CNIGA), said of their work alongside the unions.
The legal battle over prediction markets hinges on a relatively technical dispute — when is a wager on an event considered a financial instrument known as a “swap” instead of gambling?
States and tribes argue that prediction markets offer plain old gambling. Since gambling has historically been regulated at the state and tribal level, they contend these platforms fall under their jurisdiction and need to comply with their laws.
But prediction markets argue their products are distinct from traditional gambling and should be regulated as swaps by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), a stance the agency has also adopted and sought to aggressively enforce.
The dispute has quickly wound its way through the courts amid a deluge of lawsuits from prediction markets, states, tribes and the CFTC.
After a pair of appellate courts reached conflicting decisions, New Jersey asked the Supreme Court to take up its case against Kalshi in early September.
They received support, in the form of amicus briefs, from a bipartisan group of 39 state attorneys........
