ASEAN Beat | Security | Southeast Asia

At a Jakarta Conference, Two Maritime Orders Collide

The gap between legalistic and “relationalist” approaches is the region’s primary fault line when it comes to the South China Sea disputes.

An aerial view of Natuna Besar, the largest island in Indonesia’s Natuna archipelago.

Ten years after the landmark South China Sea arbitration ruling, the landmark decision was finally commemorated outside the Philippines – and in a capital Beijing would rather have avoided. On 13–14 July, a Track 1.5 conference in Jakarta, co-hosted by Philippine and Indonesian institutions, marked the anniversary of the July 12, 2016 award.

More than a conference, the event was a commemoration of the ruling – unprecedented outside the Philippines – that initially was scheduled to include Indonesian government speakers. Hosting the event in Jakarta, ASEAN’s primus inter pares, sent a signal of regional solidarity against China’s assertive actions in the South China Sea and underscored the willingness of two key maritime Southeast Asian states to shape norms governing behavior at sea.

Get to the bottom of the story

Subscribe today and join thousands of diplomats, analysts, policy professionals and business readers who rely on The Diplomat for expert Asia-Pacific coverage.

Get unlimited access to in-depth analysis you won't find anywhere else, from South China Sea tensions to ASEAN diplomacy to India-Pakistan relations. More than 5,000 articles a year.

Unlimited articles and expert analysis

Weekly newsletter with exclusive insights

16-year archive of diplomatic coverage

Ad-free reading on all devices

Support independent journalism

Already have an account? Log in.

Ten years after the landmark South China Sea arbitration ruling, the landmark decision was finally commemorated outside the Philippines – and in a capital Beijing would rather have avoided. On 13–14 July, a Track 1.5 conference in Jakarta, co-hosted by Philippine and Indonesian institutions, marked the anniversary of the July 12, 2016 award.

More than a conference, the event was a commemoration of the ruling – unprecedented outside the Philippines – that initially was scheduled to include Indonesian government speakers. Hosting the event in Jakarta, ASEAN’s primus inter pares, sent a signal of regional solidarity against China’s assertive actions in the South China Sea and underscored the willingness of two key maritime Southeast Asian states to shape norms governing behavior at sea.

The arbitral award had global implications. It clarified the legal status of maritime features, rejected China’s claim to historic rights within its “nine-dash........

© The Diplomat