From Dhaka to Cox’s Bazar: The Silent Cry of Arakan
The Rohingya Tragedy in the Memory of a Diplomat, 1991
Former Turkish Diplomat
This article examines the Rohingya exodus from Myanmar’s Rakhine region (Arakan) to Bangladesh in 1991–1992, bringing together the author’s personal recollection of a visit to refugee camps near Cox’s Bazar during his diplomatic posting in Dhaka. It explores the historical background, the exclusionary consequences of the 1982 Citizenship Law, military operations, Bangladesh’s humanitarian and diplomatic challenges, and the international community’s search for solutions. It also considers the renewed waves of violence in 2012, 2016 and 2017; Arakan’s growing geostrategic significance along the Bay of Bengal; and the memories revived years later when the author took part in the Turkish Red Crescent’s assistance to refugee children in Karachi. Projects subsequently developed by China and India are treated not as direct causes of the 1991–1992 military operations, but as indicators of the region’s increasing strategic value over time. Combining historical analysis with diplomatic memory, the article argues that at the heart of the Rohingya tragedy lie questions of citizenship, security, belonging and human dignity.
Keywords: Rohingya, Arakan, Bangladesh, Cox’s Bazar, Karachi, statelessness, refugee diplomacy.
Introduction: From Dhaka’s Misty Horizon to the Muddy Reality of Cox’s Bazar
There are journeys that remain with us, retaining their original weight in our memory no matter how many years pass, or how many cities, countries and lives come between us and the day they began. Such journeys are more than passages from one place to another; they leave deep traces on our conscience, our memory and the way we see the world. For me, 1991 marked the beginning of one such memory.
Dhaka… A city etched into memory by the humid air of Bengal, its rain-washed streets, ceaseless human tide and rivers merging along the distant horizon. A thin mist settled over the city in the mornings; heavy clouds covered the sky during the day; and sudden showers often broke in towards evening. Together, they lent the landscape a spirit that was at once mysterious and wistful. It sometimes seemed as though nature in Bengal governed not only the seasons, but human emotions as well.
Bangladesh was a land where rivers converged, where water flowed into soil and soil into life. The abundance carried by the Ganges, Brahmaputra and Meghna nourished the vast delta, while the monsoon rains could turn this country into either a corner of paradise or a harsh testing ground where people struggled against their fate. There was a profound poetry in a landscape where water, greenery and earth were intertwined. Yet behind this beauty lay another reality: poverty, social inequality, fragile lives and, at times, some of humanity’s most severe ordeals.
I was serving in Dhaka, one of the first overseas postings of my professional career, in a city alive with movement and contradictions. As life flowed vigorously through its streets, the shadow of a disaster unfolding a few hundred kilometres away would sometimes fall across the ordinary rhythm of the day. In those years, I closely followed reports emerging from Arakan, in the west of Myanmar, then known as Burma. Each new account suggested that the Rohingya Muslims living across the border were being drawn into an increasingly severe climate of oppression and violence.
During my posting in Dhaka, I did not limit myself to following the great human tragedy that had forced Rohingya Muslims to seek refuge in Bangladesh through diplomatic reports and press coverage alone. As part of a visit programme arranged at the time, I had the opportunity to visit refugee camps near Cox’s Bazar. The flight from Dhaka to Cox’s Bazar was more than a journey to the country’s south-east. It was a journey towards the very place where a human tragedy we had known through news reports was unfolding—in the midst of suffering and desperation.
When our aircraft landed at Cox’s Bazar, the sky was heavy with clouds. Rain fell as though it would never cease, and the air seemed weighed down by humidity and gloom. As we left the airport and made our way towards the camps, the rain-soaked roads, the earth turned to mud and the damp air all around us left an almost indescribable sadness within me. It was as though the sky itself shared in the suffering there, drawing a curtain of clouds over the people below.
The scene that greeted us upon reaching the camp was one of destitution beyond the power of words to convey. Frail tents stood haphazardly on ground transformed into a sea of mud; makeshift shelters had been pieced together from reeds and whatever scarce materials people could find. Leaning against one another, these fragile refuges revealed how harshly human lives could be confined. Rain trickled over the tents and reed huts, while mud clung to our feet with every step. We had to put on the boots prepared for us as part of the visit programme. Even walking here was a struggle in itself.
Yet what weighed most heavily was not the mud beneath our feet, but the human scene before our eyes. Women, elderly people, children… Some searched for a corner where they might escape the rain; others for a shelter under which to rest their heads; still others for a patch of dry ground where they could keep their families at least a little safer. People who had once owned their homes, gardens and villages were now trying to hold on to life beneath a few belongings and thin sheets of tent fabric. The children’s faces seemed to carry more fatigue and bewilderment than the joy of childhood; the elderly bore the sorrow of a life left behind; and the women carried the heavy responsibility of keeping their families together.
In the large tents set up by aid organisations, food was being distributed in an effort to provide people with at least one modest, warm meal. The containers held by those waiting in the rain were more than vessels for food under such conditions; they held the hope of making it through another day. Nearby, I noticed a small medical tent. With its limited resources, this modest medical post seemed like a small yet vital hand of hope extended to people living under the shadow of disease and malnutrition.
When I saw that tent, I thought that humanity, despite all its helplessness, had not surrendered. On one side were people searching for shelter in the rain; on the other were aid workers trying to bring them food, tend their wounds and find remedies for their illnesses. There were shattered lives on one side, and hands reaching out to help those lives stand again on the other. The sky remained overcast. The rain had not stopped, and the mud had not dried. Yet what remains most deeply etched in my memory is neither the intensity of the rain nor the wretched condition of the camps. What I have never forgotten are the faces of people struggling to hold on to life amid such deprivation and despair.
At times, we try to understand a disaster through figures: How many people had fled? How many families had abandoned their homes? How many tents had been erected, and how many people had received assistance? Yet in that camp there was a reality that no figure could convey on its own. Beneath every tent lay a life left unfinished; within every family was a home abandoned; in every child’s eyes was a sense of security that had been lost. That day, I understood once more that being a refugee is not merely crossing a border. It is being torn away from the world in which one was born and raised, and having the bond between one’s past and future severed in an instant.
Many years have passed since that journey from Dhaka to Cox’s Bazar. Yet the people I saw in the rain, among the reed huts and frail tents, remain before my eyes despite the passage of time. That experience transformed the Arakan question, for me, from an issue followed in diplomatic files into one inscribed in human memory and conscience.
1. The Historical Memory of Arakan: Identity, Belonging and the Colonial Legacy
To understand the human tragedy in Arakan, it is not enough to look only at the military operations that began in 1991. Behind this suffering lies a complex process in which centuries of historical interaction, colonial-era population and labour policies, post-independence nationalism and the state’s citizenship regime became intertwined.
Arakan lies on the coast of the Bay of Bengal, in a region where the trade networks of Bengal, South-East Asia and the Indian Ocean have intersected throughout history. Relations between Muslim merchants, sailors and settlers and the Buddhist kingdoms of Arakan shaped the region’s social fabric over many centuries. Academic literature, however, offers differing interpretations of the historical formation, naming and origins of Rohingya identity. Some studies trace the Muslim presence in the region to early patterns of trade and settlement, while others emphasise the impact of labour migration from Bengal to Arakan under British colonial rule on the later demographic structure. This contested historical background cannot justify denying Rohingya people their rights to citizenship and belonging; debates about historical origins must be kept separate from the fundamental rights of people living today.[1][2]
Under British colonial rule, Burma was administered as part of the administrative structure of British India. Administrative and economic ties between Bengal and Burma increased population movements for agricultural labour and trade. Some of this mobility became part of Arakan’s agricultural economy and local labour market. Over time, the colonial administration’s labour and population policies created conditions that fostered competition and mistrust among local communities. Yet this historical process, on its own, cannot explain the later classification of an entire Muslim community as ‘foreigners’ or ‘illegal immigrants’.
The Second World War further unsettled Arakan’s social balance. During the Japanese invasion of Burma and the British retreat, Muslim and Buddhist communities became associated with different political and military sides. In 1942, reciprocal violence, the destruction of villages and forced displacement took place. The loss of civilian lives in both communities made this period one of the historical turning points in the mistrust that would deepen in the years that followed. It is historically and morally unacceptable, however, to assign responsibility for past conflicts to an entire religious community today.[3]
The point to bear in mind is that Arakan’s history is too layered to be reduced to a single ethnic or religious narrative. Muslim and Buddhist communities have experienced not only periods of rivalry, but also examples of coexistence and mutual interaction. Yet post-independence state-building, rather than bringing this plural social heritage together under a shared framework of citizenship, increasingly moved towards deepening divisions based on identity.
2. Military Rule, the Citizenship Law and the Making of Statelessness
General Ne Win’s seizure of power in a military coup in 1962 marked one of the major turning points in the deepening exclusion of Muslims in Arakan. Instead of addressing the country’s ethnic and religious diversity through an inclusive understanding of citizenship, the government foregrounded a centralised national identity and security-based approach. Restrictions on Rohingya organisation, travel, education, religious life and employment increased.[4]
During the 1978 campaign known as Operation Nagamin (King Dragon), more than 200,000 Muslims from Arakan fled to Bangladesh. Refugees reported violations including military violence, forced displacement, sexual assault and looting of property. Most returned following international pressure, but the problems of citizenship and security remained unresolved.[5]
The 1982 Burma Citizenship Law gave exclusion a legal and administrative foundation. It organised citizenship into three categories—‘citizen’, ‘associate citizen’ and ‘naturalised citizen’—and relied on criteria relating to settlement before 1823 and membership in ethnic groups recognised by the state. Since Rohingya were not included among the recognised national groups, they faced severe obstacles to obtaining full citizenship. The law should not be interpreted as having automatically cancelled everyone’s citizenship through a single act; in practice, however, its implementation deprived the great majority of citizenship rights and led to de facto statelessness.[6]
Discrimination in travel permits and access to education and public services, restrictions on marriage and civil registration, forced labour and loss of property became part of everyday life. People were increasingly deprived of the ability to move, work and build a future in the land where they had been born.
Citizenship thus........
