menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

This Is a New Way of Doing Impeachment. The Framers Would Have Loved It.

11 0
10.11.2026

Sign up for the Slatest to get the most insightful analysis, criticism, and advice out there, delivered to your inbox daily.

If Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth does not resign in the next few days or weeks, he will almost surely be impeached by the House of Representatives. Hegseth’s impeachment will either happen immediately by a Republican-majority House in response to the eight articles of impeachment introduced by Rep. Thomas Massie on Monday, or in January, when Democrats take control of the chamber. It is even conceivable that the Senate—particularly the new majority-Democrat Senate of next year—would muster the two-thirds majority constitutionally required to convict and remove him from office.

That Hegseth is in such peril is a testament to his unique blend of arrogance, incompetence, and vulgar viciousness, as well as to America’s near-universal disapproval for Trump’s Iran war, of which Hegseth has been the prime executor and most visible champion. The secretary’s predicament is also the first practical consequence of the radically changed political environment brought about by Democrats’ midterm wipeout of Trumpian Republicans.

In the general glee (open among Democrats, covert but still common among Republicans) evoked by Hegseth’s well-deserved travails, it is easy to miss the potentially enduring significance of the particular charges levied against him by Massie. The outgoing Kentucky congressman has sometimes been dismissed as a fringe figure due to his extreme hard-line conservative stances on many subjects and his stiff-necked refusal to yield to party discipline in the Trump era. Moreover, the congressman’s crusade against Hegseth is easy to label as cheap payback against Donald Trump for the president’s successful effort to drive Massie out of office with a primary challenge. But the articles of impeachment Massie has introduced against Hegseth are extraordinarily well crafted and, if approved, have the potential to open a new era in the relations of Congress and the presidency.

Massie has proposed eight articles: three charging Hegseth with violations of the Constitution and the War Powers Act in prosecuting the Iran war without the required congressional approval; one for similar violations in conducting military operations in Yemen; one for similar violations in the kidnapping of President Nicolás Maduro of Venezuela; one for eviscerating mandatory Defense Department processes for mitigating harm to civilians in military operations thereby leading to the killing of more than 100 schoolchildren in strikes on Iran; one for directing extrajudicial killings of the occupants of boats merely suspected of engaging in drug smuggling; and one for using military processes to retaliate against Sen. Mark Kelly, a retired Navy captain, for stating that members of the armed forces are obliged to refuse unlawful orders, a violation by Hegseth of both the First Amendment and the separation of powers.

The first point to note about these articles is that they are a notable departure from either of the two prior cases in U.S. history in which a Cabinet officer has been impeached. President Ulysses S. Grant’s secretary of war, William Belknap, was impeached for taking bribes—an ordinary tawdry case of personal corruption.

President Joe Biden’s secretary of Homeland Security, Alejandro Mayorkas, was impeached (though the case was promptly dismissed by the Senate)........

© Slate