The Volokh Conspiracy

Mostly law professors | Sometimes contrarian | Often libertarian | Always independent

About The Volokh Conspiracy Editorial Independence Who we are Books Volokh Daily Email Archives Search DMCA RSS

Free Speech

Vanderbilt Student's Lawsuit Over Suspension for Alleged False Accusations Can Go Forward

Eugene Volokh | 5.5.2026 3:38 PM

From a long opinion today by Judge Waverly Crenshaw (M.D. Tenn.) in Poe v. Lowe:

Poe, a male Vanderbilt student, made social media posts about another male Vanderbilt student, Roe, and his sexual behaviors with females. [Citing court filing] showing posts by Poe's Yik Yak account, including stating that "[Roe] is a rapist" and "[Roe] slipped me a roofie this fall, but I just wasn't able to definitively proove [sic] it. When I brought it up to some of the [] brothers [from Roe's fraternity] they tried to gaslight me about it" ….

Poe was not alone—a number of posts were made about Roe by other people, including other Vanderbilt students. [Citing court filing] containing Yik Yak posts by a female Vanderbilt student, L.N., including stating that she had "personal experience" with Roe and "he is a RAPIST, that is the truth and if you don't believe it after so many girls have said it, there is nothing I can do to convince you" …. Once this came to Vanderbilt's attention, Bourgoin, Vanderbilt's Director of Student Accountability, Community Standards, and Academic Integrity, opened a disciplinary case against Poe, charging him with three violations of the Student Handbook …: disorderly conduct, harassment, and impersonating a University official or any other person….

Poe's appeal was denied by Vanderbilt's Chair of the Appellate Review Board (Lowe), and Poe was suspended for a year. Poe, who had attempted suicide after hearing of his punishment, sued Vanderbilt on various theories.

The court allowed Poe's negligence claim to go forward based on how the disciplinary outcome was reported to him:

There is no dispute that Defendants were on notice of Poe's serious mental health issues. [Citing record document] (Poe's mother emailing Bourgoin and Clapper {[Vanderbilt's] Director of Student Care Network and Student Care Coordination} that Poe "is now talking suicide We are absolutely convinced an adverse decision now will take his life"). Jamerson even testified that he had assessed Poe's suicide risk at "moderate-to-elevated." Defendants did not accommodate Poe's mother's request to move the outcome call one week. Yet, they still chose to engage in care planning with her to mitigate the risk of harm to Poe. [Citing record document] (Jamerson testifying that he "felt it was safe to move forward with adding additional precautions like having [Clapper] available to be on the [outcome] cal1, who is a licensed clinical social worker, also notifying the mom of when the date would be so that the mom was aware of when it was coming out.").

Apparently, Defendants wanted Poe to have his mother with him during the outcome call, as evidenced by the email to his mother with the target date for the meeting. Clapper also testified that when she and Bourgoin began the outcome call with Poe, she asked Poe if his mother was there. Despite Poe telling them he lied to his mother {about the scheduling of the outcome call and [told] her that it was the following day}, Bourgoin and Clapper proceeded with the outcome call.

This is evidence from which a jury could conclude that the risk that........

© Reason.com