Every revolution sells itself as the end of an old cruelty and the birth of a fairer order. Almost none of them keep that promise without first extracting a price in blood. From the guillotines of Paris to anti-colonial struggles that ended in new juntas wearing the old chains, the pattern repeats with disturbing consistency. Revolutions are rarely the clean rupture their slogans promise. They are messy, violent and almost always paid for by people who never got to choose whether the price was worth it.

This is why slogans like “seenay pe goli kha lein gay” (we will take the bullet to our chest) deserve far more scrutiny than the applause they usually receive at rallies. Such chants romanticize martyrdom as the currency of change.

History’s own ledger on revolutions is more sobering than the mythology built around them. The Russian Revolution promised to abolish the aristocracy’s grip on power and produced Stalinism. In case after case, the old absolutism was broken, but what filled the vacuum was often a new centralized authority, just as unaccountable, dressed in revolutionary language.

But they also succeeded more than history gives them credit for: divine-right monarchy as a governing principle is largely dead, constitutional frameworks did emerge from these ruptures and the modern........

© Pakistan Observer