Oct 14, 2026 13:07 pm IST

Opinion | Elon Musk, And Why He's Wrong To Just Assume That India 'Owes' Him Starlink

India should neither be intimidated by Musk's global influence nor distracted by his theatrics.

Harsh V Pant Harsh V Pant Columnist

Harsh V Pant Columnist

Elon Musk's public tirade against India's regulatory establishment is a revealing demonstration of the entitlement that increasingly characterises the world's most powerful technology billionaires. Frustrated by the delay in securing final approvals for Starlink's commercial launch in India, Musk has chosen to portray a sovereign government's regulatory process as an obstacle to technological progress and consumer welfare. His intervention reveals less about the merits of Starlink's application than about his own understanding of power, privilege, and market access.

The underlying message is difficult to miss. Musk appears to believe that because Starlink possesses advanced technology, operates across much of the world, and promises to connect underserved populations, India should expedite its entry on his terms. When New Delhi does not oblige, the implication is that the regulatory system must be dysfunctional or obstructive. This is a familiar playbook: elevate a commercial dispute into a moral crusade, cast the entrepreneur as the champion of ordinary citizens, and portray the host government as an impediment to progress. It may generate headlines and rally supporters on social media. It is no substitute for engaging with the sovereign requirements of the Indian state.

India must reject this framing unequivocally. Its regulatory institutions do not derive their legitimacy from Elon Musk's approval, nor do they require validation from a foreign billionaire who mistakes global commercial influence for political authority. India is an independent country, not a market in which powerful technology executives can demand preferential treatment and publicly pressure the government when they encounter regulatory resistance.

The Indian government's response has been appropriately firm. The Ministry of Communications has maintained that the satellite communications authorisation framework is fair and non-discriminatory. Starlink, Reliance Jio's satellite business, and Bharti-backed Eutelsat OneWeb are broadly at the same regulatory stage, with mandatory security assessments still to be completed before spectrum can be assigned. Communications Minister Jyotiraditya Scindia has reiterated that India does not permit monopolies and that commercial operations can begin only after the necessary security requirements are met and spectrum........

© NDTV