menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

There’s a Reason No President Before Trump Authorized War With Iran

40 0
20.03.2026

For nearly a half-century, U.S. leaders, and perhaps Americans themselves, have viewed Iran as the “ultimate rogue.” Tehran’s unchanging anti-American ideology combined with a religiously dogmatic leadership have set it apart in the American imagination from other difficult enemies.

Just two weeks before U.S. President Donald Trump launched the current war against Iran, Secretary of State Marco Rubio expressed a long-standing view of the regime’s leaders, arguing: “These people make policy decisions on the basis of pure theology. That’s how they make their decisions. So it’s hard to do a deal with Iran.”

For nearly a half-century, U.S. leaders, and perhaps Americans themselves, have viewed Iran as the “ultimate rogue.” Tehran’s unchanging anti-American ideology combined with a religiously dogmatic leadership have set it apart in the American imagination from other difficult enemies.

Just two weeks before U.S. President Donald Trump launched the current war against Iran, Secretary of State Marco Rubio expressed a long-standing view of the regime’s leaders, arguing: “These people make policy decisions on the basis of pure theology. That’s how they make their decisions. So it’s hard to do a deal with Iran.”

The rhetoric was such a staple of Washington talk about Iran that hardly anyone noticed. But this profoundly ingrained anti-Iran sentiment in Washington helped set the stage for Trump taking the United States to war. It is a set of attitudes fueled in part by decades of hostile Iranian actions, from the original sin of taking U.S. diplomats hostage in Tehran during the 1979 revolution to decades of support for militant groups across the region and acts of terrorism globally, all of which were supercharged by a nuclear standoff beginning in the early 2000s.

Yet the current war cannot be seen as merely a natural progression of U.S.-Iranian hostility. Despite a deep well of animosity, previous U.S. presidents never went this far. U.S. policy largely defaulted to containment, drawing on policies short of war such as economic sanctions, diplomatic isolation, and military deterrence. Successive administrations, Democratic and Republican, even attempted diplomacy to resolve U.S. differences with Iran, though domestic politics, in both Washington and Tehran, repeatedly stifled any chance of sustainable breakthroughs. U.S. officials debated military options in previous administrations but ultimately ruled them out, viewing the risks as too high and the outcomes as too uncertain. Until now.

Trump’s decision to choose war over diplomacy continues a well-trodden path of confrontational attitudes and policies, but more importantly, it also marks a radical departure, taking the United States on a path that is unlikely to “solve” Iran. Trump claims that he has done what no previous president “had the guts” to do. But his overreach will bring infamy rather than glory, with dire regional and global consequences that will outlive his presidency.

It seems unlikely that, in the months leading up to this U.S.-Israel attack on Iran, Trump’s envoy Steve Witkoff and son-in-law Jared Kushner were engaged in genuine attempts to strike a diplomatic deal to stave off war. The track record of U.S. attacks in the midst of diplomacy, as occurred last June during the 12-day war, did not bode well for dealmaking. Then there were the wide gaps in positions on the nuclear and missile issues as well as Washington’s maximalist demands, premised on a belief........

© Foreign Policy