menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

SALTZBURG | Lindsay Clancy's Jury Didn't Fail, The Law's 183-Year-Old Theory of the Mind Did

20 0
09.11.2026

The law has to decide when a person is responsible for what they did. To make that call, it relies on a picture of the mind that was inherited from history, not built from science, and that picture breaks in ways the legal system has stopped noticing. 

The trial of Lindsay Clancy is one that the old picture cannot handle: A mother who did not deny what she did, a defense built on what her prescribed medication did to her mind and a jury that could not decide what to call it. 11 jurors in Plymouth, Massachusetts were prepared to adjudge her not criminally responsible for killing her three children. One was not. After seven days of deliberation, Judge William Sullivan declared a mistrial on Sept. 4. Clancy never contested that she strangled her children in their basement in January 2023, and the holdout juror has since said he had no doubts about her guilt. The jury still deadlocked, under one of the most defense-favorable insanity standards in the country: Prosecutors must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant could both appreciate the wrongfulness of her conduct and control it. If a jury cannot reach a verdict under those rules, on those facts, the problem is not the jury. 

The standard descends, like nearly every insanity test in the United States, from the M’Naghten rules, drafted by English judges in 1843. Its model of a person is simple: a single, rational self who either knows right from wrong or does not. Psychiatry has been rebuilt several times since; the legal model of the mind has barely moved.

Prosecutors told Clancy’s jury she acted “intentionally, rationally and swiftly,” pointing to her phone, her journal and her searches for ways to kill. Under this model, planning is proof of sanity. Her lawyer has had to argue the........

© Cornell Daily Sun