menu_open Columnists
Derek Mcarthur

Derek Mcarthur

Herald Scotland

We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Is Record Store Day helping to revive our record shops... or is it a total sham?

Is Record Store Day helping to revive our record shops... or is it a total sham?

The annual return of Record Store Day is upon us next month. It is a day designed to celebrate the record shop, the records, and everything...

latest 0

Herald Scotland

Derek Mcarthur

Why it is worth reading the Japanese writer who disembowelled himself In 1970, Yukio Mishima, author and ultranationalist, tied up the commandant of a Tokyo military base and stepped onto the balcony. He read his prepared speech to the bewildered soldiers below, retreated inside, then disembowelled himself.

Why it is worth reading the Japanese writer who disembowelled himself In 1970, Yukio Mishima, author and ultranationalist, tied up the commandant of a Tokyo military base and stepped onto the balcony. He read his prepared speech to the bewildered soldiers below, retreated inside, then disembowelled himself.

In 1970, author and poet Yukio Mishima tied up the commandant of a Tokyo military base and stepped onto the balcony. He read his prepared speech to...

21.02.2025 3

Herald Scotland

Derek Mcarthur

There is no option with Kanye West but to separate art from artist

There is no option with Kanye West but to separate art from artist

Can you separate the art from the artist? Why this remains a discussion is a mystery. Yes, you can. And yes, you should. Separate it all from the...

14.02.2025 10

Herald Scotland

Derek Mcarthur

Architects hate acclaimed film The Brutalist… who said it matters what they think? What if your passion in life made it onto the big screen and you noticed everything it got wrong? The world of architecture is currently experiencing this feeling.

What if your passion in life made it onto the big screen and you noticed everything it got wrong? The architecture world is currently experiencing...

07.02.2025 10

Herald Scotland

Derek Mcarthur

I asked the market-wrecking AI to write an opinion column for me. So how did it do? The Chinese AI model DeepSeek has shaken the tech world, but will it shake a humble opinion columnist?

AI was supposed to be the shiny centrepiece of the new American tech revolution - until it wasn’t. This week US tech giants took an existential...

01.02.2025 5

Herald Scotland

Derek Mcarthur

This film veteran was stunned when he asked AI to give him ideas ‘Why should writers sit around for months searching for a good idea when AI can provide one in seconds?’ asked film icon Paul Schrader

Before Paul Schrader sat down to write the script for 1976’s seminal Taxi Driver, he made sure to reread one novel in particular. That was Nausea,...

24.01.2025 3

Herald Scotland

Derek Mcarthur

Nosferatu is a perfect film… so why is it actually an awful film?

The original template-setting Nosferatu could have never seen the light of day again. Marred by legal issues over its obvious unsolicited adaptation...

17.01.2025 3

Herald Scotland

Derek Mcarthur

If Northern Ireland is now culturally relevant, why isn’t Scotland? TV sitcom Derry Girls and rap group Kneecap have helped give Northern Ireland a new cultural relevance – but where is that relevancy for Scotland?

Is Scottish arts and culture self-contained, inside its walls, too busy staring down at its own navel for anyone else to notice? Northern Ireland is...

10.01.2025 6

Herald Scotland

Derek Mcarthur

Netflix and the films no one is actually watching Why is dialogue so obvious in Netflix films? Because no one is actually watching to know what's happening otherwise.

The omnipresent streaming giant Netflix and its competitors are certainly a different beast from any film or TV production and distribution company...

03.01.2025 6

Herald Scotland

Derek Mcarthur

The death of Pier Paolo Pasolini still haunts me so Pier Paolo Pasolini's murder is shrouded in a haunting mystery. Why did a groundbreaking filmmaker fall to what looks like political assassination?

2024 was a chaotic year, as always. Each year does seem to be adding a touch more chaos than the last recently. Strangely enough, it was nothing in...

27.12.2024 5

Herald Scotland

Derek Mcarthur

Five Unspuns you might have missed in 2024

There were over 250 editions of Unspun published in 2024, our newsletter where we analyse, dissect and discuss the political happenings of Scotland...

27.12.2024 3

Herald Scotland

Derek Mcarthur

War film glory is over and concerning – we still shouldn’t prejudge A24’s Warfare The Iraq War was a disaster but why should we judge a film for its crimes?

In the Errol Morris documentary American Dharma, Morris sits down with Donald Trump strategist Steve Bannon to discuss politics and films in an...

20.12.2024 9

Herald Scotland

Derek Mcarthur

Respected filmmakers directing mainstream slop is no win for the little guy

This month sees the release of Mufasa: The Lion King, another entry in Disney’s photorealistic revival of its older, much-loved animated...

13.12.2024 6

Herald Scotland

Derek Mcarthur

Using your phone in the cinema? Well, expect to be publicly shamed The film adaptation of Broadway musical Wicked has recently hit cinemas, igniting a furore over audience singalongs. Now another furore has taken centre stage: documenting the experience with phones.

A few weeks ago, I wrote about how audience behaviour in cinemas has been getting worse in recent years. Now with the film adaptation of Broadway...

26.11.2024 5

Herald Scotland

Derek Mcarthur

It's not just Edinburgh – Glasgow has its fair share of uni toffs too From the Russell Group’s Glasgow University to the well-renowned Glasgow School of Art, there is no respite from the Saltburn-esque toffs.

When Dani Garavelli wrote in this newspaper about the derision and condescension of working-class students by the private school-educated at...

21.11.2024 3

Herald Scotland

Derek Mcarthur

‘Think of all the great art we’ll get from a Trump win…’ Donald Trump's win in 2016 was supposed to unleash an artistic renaissance – where is that sentiment now?

One of the supposed silver linings of Donald Trump’s presidential win in 2016 was all the great art we would get. The flames of discontent were to...

14.11.2024 4

Herald Scotland

Derek Mcarthur

Why are you laughing? This is a serious film...

A spectre is haunting your local cinema – the spectre of having no idea how to behave when in a cinema. No, I’m not the fun police. Nor am I...

31.10.2024 2

Herald Scotland

Derek Mcarthur

This musician hates her fans making constant jokes. She is right to be so angry.

“Nobody takes anything f*cking seriously anymore,” starts a now-deleted rant from ambitious alternative musician Ethel Cain. “It makes me feel so...

24.10.2024 3

Herald Scotland

Derek Mcarthur

TikTokifying Billie Holiday surely must be against the law On social video app TikTok, speeding up and slowing down music is par for the course, a necessity in fitting tempo to different dance trends. Jazz singing legend Billie Holiday saw one of her several recordings of ‘Solitude’ reach their algorithm.

The art of speeding up and slowing down music is probably not new to anyone. Many first found such wonders mischievously playing around with the...

17.10.2024 4

Herald Scotland

Derek Mcarthur

Why is Chappell Roan even trying to be a famous pop star?

The biggest come-up of the year surely belongs to pop star Chappell Roan. The singer has seen a neck breaking rise in the past few months, becoming...

26.09.2024 4

Herald Scotland

Derek Mcarthur

No, Kurt Cobain was not killed by his wife Courtney Love According to certain fans, authors, and investigators, Kurt Cobain’s famous 1994 suicide by shotgun was not the consequence of a struggling man with the entire world on his shoulders.

Fandom can be an intense thing. Unsettling, even. Not only are there swarms of Beatles fans who think that the involvement of Yoko Ono is solely...

19.09.2024 3

Herald Scotland

Derek Mcarthur

I don’t want to hear ‘Yoko Ono broke up The Beatles’ ever again

Some myths apparently never die. For some, it’s called conventional wisdom. The conventional wisdom that Yoko Ono broke up the most famous pop...

12.09.2024 2

Herald Scotland

Derek Mcarthur

Giving over your biggest hit for a few grand? No thanks, Grand Theft Auto Being asked for your song to be licensed for one of the biggest franchises ever would normally be a cause to celebrate, but for Heaven 17’s Martyn Ware, the offer was nothing short of appalling.

Being asked for your song to be licensed for one of the biggest franchises ever would normally be a cause to celebrate, but for Heaven 17’s Martyn...

09.09.2024 3

Herald Scotland

Derek Mcarthur

Can we please move on from thinking pop music is the best thing ever? Poptimism attempted to correct the cultural perspective on pop music – but the scales have now tipped too far in its favour.

In the 2010s, a major consensus shift took over music. Everyone started to take pop music far more seriously, with the term ‘poptimist’ springing...

05.09.2024 1

Herald Scotland

Derek Mcarthur

Arts funding in Scotland is drowning in a vast sea of neglect Publicly funded arts commonly play martyr in budgets, disposed of without a care by artless politicians who see the arts as a luxury, not a cultural necessity.

Scotland’s arts and culture sector is drowning, and there is no life raft. No skin comes off the backs of governments when cutting the arts is...

21.08.2024 8

Herald Scotland

Derek Mcarthur

Glasgow School of Art is right to leave X, it is no place for art or artists And so it’s written, Glasgow School of Art will no longer post on the social media platform formerly known as Twitter, X. You don’t have to squint to see why.

And so it’s written, Glasgow School of Art will no longer post on the social media platform formerly known as Twitter, X. You don’t have to squint...

15.08.2024 2

Herald Scotland

Derek Mcarthur

David Lynch won’t step foot on a film set again – time to give him his flowers It is unfortunate that Lynch will never grace a film set again to craft another dream or nightmare, but he doesn’t have to.

David Lynch says he will never retire – but he certainly won’t set foot on a film set again. That was the news when the 78-year-old surrealist cult...

08.08.2024 2

Herald Scotland

Derek Mcarthur

When you die, are you ‘unalived’? The strange world of social media algospeak

“And that’s when he unalived himself, as well as his wife and children,” says one true crime TikTok user as she demonstrates her new Wonderskin...

25.07.2024 2

Herald Scotland

Derek Mcarthur