menu_open Columnists
Andrew Silow-Carroll

Andrew Silow-Carroll

The Jewish Week

We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

What Timothée Chalamet got right about opera, ballet — and my mornings in synagogue

On a Saturday in January I went to Shabbat services in the morning and the New York City Ballet in the evening.  By which I mean, maybe Timothée...

11.03.2026 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

Buffeted on the left and the right, these liberal Zionists are holding their ground

When J Street, the liberal pro-Israel lobby, met last weekend in Washington for its annual policy conference, it had to scramble to adjust to a joint...

05.03.2026 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

I asked my Jewish readers if they’re Zionists. Here’s what they told me.

The recent survey conducted by the Jewish Federations of North America on American Jews’ attitudes toward Israel and Zionism has sparked more than...

01.03.2026 40

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

It’s not just the kids: A third of US Jews 75+ don’t call themselves ‘Zionists’

The newest Jewish Federations of North America survey has already generated its share of anxious headlines: Only 37% of American Jews say they...

13.02.2026 100

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

Why Jewish law cares about mother birds, baby goats and the bonds of animal families

Beth Berkowitz was 12 years old, sitting at Shabbat dinner at Camp Ramah in the Berkshires, when she noticed something she could not unsee: tiny...

02.02.2026 80

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

This Jewish artist fought Nazis with a paintbrush, when art like his still mattered 

I remember being freaked out, and fascinated, by my parents’ copy of Hans Christian Andersen fairy tales. It featured these especially lurid...

09.01.2026 20

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

Here’s how I make each day count: I keep a diary

In January 2011, I wrote my first entry in a five-year diary. It seems I watched “No Country for Old Men” and had “anxiety over … board...

03.01.2026 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

A timely New York exhibition immerses listeners in voices from the Holocaust

A new exhibit at the New York Historical, “The Recordings: Voices from the ‘Shoah’ Tapes,” begins with a statement from Louise Mirrer, the...

05.12.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

They had status, safety and power — and still chose to defy Hitler

Jonathan Freedland didn’t set out to write a guidebook to resistance. He was researching the story of Rudolf Vrba, the young Jewish escapee from...

24.11.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

Philip Roth’s latest biographer wants Jews to read him again — without the guilt 

It was a scandal right out of a Philip Roth novel: Days after the publication in 2021 of his long-awaited biography of Roth, author Blake Bailey was...

27.10.2025 8

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

Sarah Hurwitz wants Jews to stop apologizing and start learning

Sarah Hurwitz calls her first book, “ Here All Along,” a “love letter” to Jewish tradition. Describing a journey begun when she worked as a...

13.10.2025 8

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

How ‘holding space’ became a post-Oct. 7 mantra of grief and comfort

As Sukkot and the anniversary of the Oct. 7 attacks approached, I received separate emails from two different Jewish organizations with what to me was...

08.10.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

Why a historian thinks Jews are living through a ‘high tide’ of American antisemitism

In December 2023, Pamela Nadell, a professor of Jewish history at American University, testified alongside the presidents of Harvard, the...

29.09.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

We asked rabbis, ‘What are Jews most hungry to hear this new year?’

It’s been a year. The war on Hamas rages on. Forty-eight hostages, alive and dead, remain in captivity. Israel scored notable victories in its...

20.09.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

Alex Edelman and fans of ‘Long Story Short’ may disagree, but a new book says Jewish humor is dying

On stage last Sunday at the Jewish Theological Seminary, the comedian Alex Edelman told a Jewish joke that he said he once read in an academic...

15.09.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

25 years ago, he wrote the book on ‘Jew vs. Jew.’ Now Samuel Freedman is seeing new and deeper divisions.

When Samuel Freedman published “ Jew vs. Jew: The Struggle for the Soul of American Jewry ” in August 2000, he described a community torn...

08.09.2025 20

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

Yosef Blau, author of an Orthodox rabbis’ letter calling out Israel, responds to his critics

For 48 years, until he moved to Israel earlier this year, Rabbi Yosef Blau was the “m ashgiach ruchani ” at Yeshiva University, a revered figure...

29.08.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

Jew vs. Jew rhetoric breaks hearts in a bitter internal debate about the Gaza war

After weeks of mounting pressure on Israel to address reports of a humanitarian crisis in Gaza, with longtime allies lining up to condemn the...

18.08.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

The subject was Gaza, but Jon Stewart and Peter Beinart had a whole lot to say about Judaism

Jon Stewart hosted writer Peter Beinart on “The Daily Show” Monday night, for a conversation in which the two Jewish liberals agreed that the war...

31.07.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

Why ‘beach reading’ is a joke on Jews like me

I’m reading a new novel by an Israeli author that has nothing to do with the war in Gaza, or any current crisis for that matter.  I can’t tell...

25.07.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

Why some think the new ‘Superman’ movie is about the war in Gaza

An amateur film critic named Evan gave the new “Superman” movie five out of five stars. Writing on the Letterboxd platform , they praised the...

17.07.2025 20

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

He wrote the book on American Jewish history. Stepping back from teaching, Jonathan Sarna says he has plenty of chapters still to go.

Journalists I know joke that the only Jewish historian they ever need to call is Jonathan Sarna.   Jews and the Civil War ? Sarna knows where the...

07.07.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

How much can Israelis take? A trauma expert finds out

The late singer-songwriter Meir Ariel had a hit song that Israelis tend to invoke at times of crisis: “Avarnu et Par’o, Na’avor Gam et Zeh” ...

30.06.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

Ana Levy-Lyons, a former Unitarian Universalist minister and future rabbi, wants to cure what ails the secular left

Ana Levy-Lyons was in her 20s when she found out she was Jewish. During her childhood in Tenafly, New Jersey, her family never spoke about what her...

19.06.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

These therapists give a name to the way Jewish distress has been ignored since Oct. 7: ‘Traumatic invalidation’

Miri Bar-Halpern and Jaclyn Wolfman don’t use the term “gaslighting” in their paper on Jewish trauma after Oct. 7, but they might as well have....

12.06.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

Aaron Lansky built a home for 1.5 million Yiddish books. Now he’s handing over the keys. 

Steven Spielberg had already donated money to the Yiddish Book Center when he asked if the center’s founder, Aaron Lansky, might fly out to Los...

09.06.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

Israeli embassy staffers shooting or Capital Jewish Museum murders? To some, a few words can make a big difference.

Following the fatal shooting last week of two employees of the Israeli embassy outside the Capital Jewish Museum in Washington D.C. on May 21, Rabbi...

31.05.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

Two writers offer strikingly different views of the ‘state of the Jews’

Last Tuesday night, the author and podcaster Dan Senor told an enthusiastic crowd at New York’s 92nd Street Y that despite a rising tide of...

19.05.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

The 20th century was very good for these Jewish icons. Is the Golden Age really over?

Has David Denby written about an American Jewish golden age precisely at the moment it is ending? In his new book “Eminent Jews,” Denby...

12.05.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

A family memoir is about the search for a Jewish homeland, from Zion to Texas

Growing up in London, almost everything Rachel Cockerell knew about the British Jewish writer Israel Zangwill could be summed up in three words:...

25.04.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

Who killed Jesus? It wasn’t the Jews, writes a scholar of Roman law.

This again? Having grown up in the years after Nostra Aetate – the Vatican document rejecting the traditional accusation that the Jews were...

19.04.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

How ‘October 8’ and ‘The Encampments,’ two new documentaries on America post-Oct. 7, talk right past each other

George Orwell disliked peace propaganda as much as he disliked war propaganda. Like war propaganda, he wrote, peace propaganda “ concentrates on...

09.04.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

Dara Horn’s gonzo, time-traveling children’s Passover book wants people to love living Jews

“All of my books are the same book,” said Dara Horn, the author of seven novels and the 2021 essay collection, “People Love Dead Jews,” which...

04.04.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

How the Yiddish writer Chaim Grade’s last novel was rescued from the archives, and wrestled into print

Sixty years after he first began serializing it in the Yiddish press, and 42 years after publisher Alfred A. Knopf acquired the book, “Sons and...

28.03.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

These Modern Orthodox and observant Jews want to change their community’s conversation around the Gaza war

26.03.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

‘Resounding no’ to ‘strongly support’: JTA readers weigh in on Trump’s bid to deport Mahmoud Khalil

18.03.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

Two middle-aged women defied the Nazis. One ‘wrote’ a book that betrayed the other. 

09.03.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

A Jewish atheist calls out evangelicals for undermining democracy — and Christianity

23.02.2025 8

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

Was the Jewish Bronx the ‘paradise’ that it seemed?

09.02.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

Sen. Ron Wyden says the Democrats need ‘chutzpah’ to return to power

02.02.2025 20

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

A gift shop at Auschwitz? New films and a graphic memoir explore the contradictions of ‘dark tourism’

26.01.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

Why everyone is quoting Hannah Arendt, sometimes even accurately

19.01.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

What an obituary writer learned by saying goodbye to hundreds of people

In June, the writer Lore Segal, who had started hospice at her home in Manhattan, sent an email to her friends. “I am not sad or angry or afraid,”...

08.01.2025 20

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

The Lower East Side anti-Jewish riot that changed the way Jews do politics

You might be forgiven for never having heard of the worst anti-Jewish riot in American history. It happened on the Lower East Side over a century...

05.01.2025 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll

The world after Oct. 7, and before Trump 2.0: The essential Jewish conversations of 2024

The trauma of Oct. 7 and the war that has raged since dominated the thoughts of Jewish opinion writers in 2024, and the essays JTA published in its...

31.12.2024 10

The Jewish Week

Andrew Silow-Carroll