Agnipath: When Generals Stopped Speaking Truth to Power
Listen to this article:
Chandigarh: The recent retreat from the disastrous 2022 Agnipath scheme for recruiting Personnel Below Officer Rank (PBOR) on limited tours of duty, which the top service brass not only helped formulate but also actively defended to please the Bharatiya Janata Party-led (BJP-led) government, has sparked a lively debate on social media.
A series of WhatsApp posts after Chief of Defence Staff General N.S. Raja Subramani recanted Agnipath on November 4 recalls a time when senior commanders and service chiefs were prepared to boldly challenge political leaders when they believed the interests of the armed forces were at stake.
One such message was shared by a two-star Indian Army veteran, who has asked not to be identified for fear of repercussions, and recalls an episode from the early years after Independence that illustrates the forthrightness associated with an earlier generation of military commanders.
According to this post, whose broad account is supported by several historical references, Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru is said to have suggested at a gathering of senior Army commanders that, since Indian officers lacked the experience to lead the Army, a British general should be appointed for a limited period until they were better equipped to take over.
Many officials and politicians at the gathering reportedly nodded in agreement. But Lieutenant General Nathu Singh Rathore from the erstwhile princely state of Dungarpur in Rajasthan, educated at Mayo College, Ajmer, and subsequently trained at the Royal Military College at Sandhurst in the UK, took sharp issue with the suggestion. Known for his forthright views and frequent run-ins with both British and Indian military authorities, he reportedly retorted: “Sir, we do not have enough experience to govern a country either. Should we therefore appoint a British Prime Minister to lead India?”
His tart response, recounted by Major General V.K. Singh in his account of Nathu Singh, drawing on papers made available to him by the latter’s family, was greeted by stunned silence. And while Gen Singh’s exact riposte cannot be independently confirmed from contemporary records, the episode more than captures the spirit of an earlier generation of senior Indian soldiers prepared to question political authority when they believed the interests of the armed forces were at stake.
Nehru is then said to have asked Nathu Singh whether he would be willing to become Army chief. Singh reportedly replied, with characteristic bluntness, that the Army already had a “very talented officer” in General K.M. Cariappa, who was better qualified for the appointment. Nehru agreed, and Cariappa became India’s first commander-in-chief on January 15, 1949, retiring in 1953 and being conferred the rank of field marshal in 1986, four years before his death.
“Whatever the precise circumstances – and wording – of the exchange, it reflects an ethos associated with an earlier generation of militarymen,”said a three-star Army veteran in Chandigarh, declining to be named as he was speaking on a sensitive matter.
Also read: Agnipath: The Military’s Four-Year March Into a Six-Year Mess
The nub of the........
