I believe Israel did not commit genocide in Gaza. This open letter asks Adam Brody to withdraw his accusation—and challenges the idea that using the word “genocide” has become a prerequisite for caring about Palestinians.

“Put me down as thinking it’s a genocide,” you told GQ.

Put me down as asking you to recant.

I believe unequivocally that Israel did not commit genocide in Gaza. I share the conviction behind Benjamin Netanyahu’s description of the accusation as “the greatest lie of the century.” But my objection to your words does not depend on accepting a prime minister’s authority. It depends on the evidence—and on refusing to confuse a declaration of solidarity with a demonstrated conclusion.

What troubles me most is how this accusation can become a test of moral belonging.

Someone says, “Palestinian children must be protected.” They are told that is insufficient. Someone says, “This suffering must end.” Still insufficient. They must say “genocide.” Only then have they demonstrated that they care.

I reject that demand.

Palestinian lives matter before anyone chooses a slogan. Their protection should command support from people who disagree about the war. Making compassion conditional on accepting a particular accusation turns human suffering into a loyalty test.

I do not know whether you felt any such pressure. I will not invent your motives. But your declaration participates in a public conversation where qualification can be treated as cowardice and disagreement as indifference. In that atmosphere,........

© The Times of Israel (Blogs)