Love as Law, Law as Love (Bamidbar, Covenant & Conversation)
On the face of it the connections between the sedra and haftara of Bamidbar are slender.[1] The first has to do with demography. Bamidbar begins with a census of the people. The haftara begins with Hosea’s vision of a time when “the number of the children of Israel will be like the sand on the seashore which cannot be measured or numbered.” There was a time when the Israelites could be counted; the day will come when they will be countless. That is one contrast between the future and the past.
The second goes deeper. The sedra and the book that bears its name are called Bamidbar, meaning “in the wilderness”. The book is about the wilderness years in both a physical and spiritual sense: a time of wandering and internal conflict. Hosea, however, foresees a time when God will bring the people back to the desert and there enact a second honeymoon:
I will lead her into the wilderness and speak tenderly to her . . . There she will respond as in the days of her youth, As in the day she came out of Egypt. (Hosea 2:14)
I will lead her into the wilderness and speak tenderly to her . . . There she will respond as in the days of her youth, As in the day she came out of Egypt. (Hosea 2:14)
What gives the haftara its special resonance, however, is the fact that Bamidbar is almost always read on the Shabbat preceding Shavuot, the festival of the giving of the Torah at Mount Sinai. The fact that tradition chose this of all prophetic passages tells us something deeply moving about how the Jewish people understood this festival, and about the Torah itself as the living connection between a people and God.
The story of Hosea is one of the strangest of that great chain of visionaries we call the Prophets. It is the story of a marriage. The prophet married a woman called Gomer. He was deeply in love with her. We can infer this, because of all the prophets, Hosea is the most eloquent and passionate on the subject of love. Gomer, however, proved faithless. She left home, had a series of lovers, was serially unfaithful, and was eventually forced to sell herself into slavery. Yet Hosea, caught between anger and tender longing, found that he could not relinquish his love for her.
In a flash of prophetic insight, God leads him to understand that his own personal experience mirrors that between God and the Israelites. He had rescued them from slavery, led them through the wilderness, and brought them to their new home, the land of Israel. But the people proved faithless. They worshipped other gods. They were promiscuous in their spiritual attachments. By rights, says God, I should have abandoned them. I should have called them (as the prophet called his third child) Lo-ammi, “you are not My people”. Yet God’s love is inextinguishable. He too cannot let go. Whatever the people’s sins, He will bring them back into the desert, the scene of their first love, and their marriage will be renewed.
The Talmud in Pesachim gives an........
