The World Aunt Freda Carried
Last month, my aunt, Freda Steinberg, née Guttentag, passed away in Jerusalem, at the age of more than one hundred.
Tomorrow evening marks the yahrzeit of my father, Mechel Max Guttentag ז״ל — Aunt Freda’s elder brother. As I write about her life and passing, I find the two memories naturally intertwined. In her voice, her gestures and her quiet dignity, I often glimpsed something of my father still present. Their generation belonged to a world now largely vanished, yet through both of them its values — Torah, family, refinement and steadfastness — continue to speak.
Aunt Freda died as she had lived for more than seven decades: in Eretz Yisrael, surrounded by generations of family. To her children, grandchildren, great-grandchildren and great-great-grandchildren, she was the family matriarch — wise, dignified, humorous, refined, and deeply present in their lives.
But her passing also represents something larger. It marks the closing of another living doorway into a generation of Anglo-Jews who carried the world of British and European Orthodoxy into the emerging life of Israel — quietly, seriously, without slogans, and with deep faith.
Aunt Freda was, in many ways, a quintessential English lady. She had elegance, gentleness and dignity. She was educated, thoughtful, cultured and well read. Yet her Englishness was never merely social polish. It rested on a strong Jewish foundation.
She came from the Guttentag family of Newcastle and Gateshead, and through her mother from the Winegarten family of London — families rooted in Torah, education, communal responsibility and Orthodox Jewish life.
As a young woman, she would cycle from her parental home in Newcastle over the bridge across the River Tyne to attend lessons at the newly established seminary of Mr Kohn in Gateshead. She was among the early students of what later became Gateshead Seminary, Beis Hamedrash Lemoroth, one of the great institutions of Torah education for women in the English-speaking world.
That detail has always stayed with me. Before she became part of the story of Israel, she belonged to another story too: the reconstruction and deepening of Orthodox Jewish life in Britain before and after the war. She came from a world that valued refinement, education, family, modesty, seriousness and Torah.
In the 1940s, family recollection places her teaching in London, I believe at one of the Hasmonean schools associated with Rabbi Dr Solomon Schonfeld’s remarkable postwar educational work. That setting matters. Hasmonean was part of the great effort to rebuild Orthodox Jewish education in Britain — to give Jewish children not only schooling, but an Orthodox future. It was there, I believe, that she met Joshua Shlomo “Solly” Steinberg, from the distinguished Jewish community of Dublin. Solly shared her world of teaching, learning and quiet........
