Debate teaches a simple lesson: the strongest argument is not the one you believe most deeply, but the one that survives contact with a skeptical audience. Competitive Debate is a game; it has rules, time limits, and moderation to ensure every voice is heard equally.

But outside the debate chamber, there are no rules. There is no moderator. And persuasion comes down to whose argument resonates.

Winning a debate requires the buildup of a winning narrative, a narrative that, thus far, supporters of Israel have been unable to find. Worryingly, new polls suggest that a majority of Americans now view Israel unfavorably. If we actually want to persuade anyone outside our own shrinking camp, we need to stop repeating slogans and start making arguments that hold up under pressure.

There are three arguments we should be making and almost never do.

The Irreversibility Argument (The 9 Million Reality)

There are currently over 9 million Israelis. Of those, approximately 7 million are Jewish. About 10% hold more than one citizenship. That means that the overwhelming majority do not.

This matters because a growing narrative in Western discourse assumes Jewish Israelis can simply leave. That we are temporary,........

© The Times of Israel (Blogs)