The popular image of America’s founding is familiar: powdered wigs, Protestant gentlemen, English legal theory, Enlightenment philosophy, and a rebellion led by men whose names became national scripture: Washington, Jefferson, Adams, Madison, Franklin, Hamilton. It is not a false picture, but it is an incomplete one.

The American founding was never only a story of Anglo-Christian elites sitting in Philadelphia and writing documents. It was also a story of merchants, financiers, immigrants, religious minorities, biblical imagination, and communities that saw in the American Revolution a chance to build something radically different from the old European order.

Among those overlooked threads is the Jewish one. 

To be clear, none of the formal signers of the Declaration of Independence or the Constitution were practicing Jews. That fact matters. History should not be rewritten into fantasy. But history should also not be narrowed until only the men with signatures at the bottom of parchment count as founders. A nation is not built only by those who write its philosophy. It is built by those who finance it, fight for it, pray for it, organize for it, and give it a moral language.

By that broader and more honest definition, the Jewish contribution to America’s founding was not marginal. It was woven into the birth of the republic.

The most fascinating place to begin is Alexander Hamilton. Hamilton was not a practicing Jew in public life, and mainstream historians generally present him as a Christian statesman who was notably sympathetic to Jews rather than as a Jewish founder himself. But the debate over his origins is not invented out of thin air. Scholars have explored Hamilton’s childhood in the Caribbean, his mother Rachel Faucette, the Lavien family connection, and the claim that Hamilton received part of his early education in a Jewish school on Nevis. Andrew Porwancher’s work has pushed this debate further, arguing that Hamilton may have been born and raised in a Jewish environment, though even sympathetic treatments often frame the claim as probabilistic rather than settled fact.

That distinction is important. The responsible argument is not Hamilton was definitely Jewish. The stronger argument is this: Hamilton’s early exposure to Jewish life in the Caribbean helps explain why he was unusually comfortable with commercial modernity, religious pluralism, and the inclusion of Jews in the civic order of the new United States.

Hamilton’s America was not a closed agrarian republic frozen in old European hierarchies. It was a commercial nation. A banking nation. A credit nation. A republic that needed financial architecture as much as political ideals. In that sense, Hamilton’s world was closer to the Atlantic mercantile networks........

© The Times of Israel (Blogs)