menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Devotion 20 — Sh’ma and Institutions: When Systems Learn to Listen

47 0
12.04.2026

Scripture“Hear, O Israel: The Lord is our God, the Lord is one.”— Deuteronomy 6:4

“Let justice roll down like waters, and righteousness like an ever-flowing stream.”— Amos 5:24

The Sh’ma begins with a command: Hear.This command is often understood at the level of the individual, but it is also meant for the community. Israel is addressed as a people, not just as isolated individuals. Hearing, in this sense, is a shared responsibility.

What is true for individuals is also true for institutions.

Listening is not only a personal practice. It can—and must—shape the systems that organize our common life. Schools, governments, congregations, and organizations all make decisions that affect many lives. These decisions are never neutral. They reflect what institutions are willing to hear—and what they choose to ignore.

When institutions remain open to listening—to feedback, to criticism, and to the lived experiences of those they serve—they become capable of growth. They adapt. They learn. They correct course when needed.

But when systems stop listening, the consequences are serious.

They do not simply become inefficient or outdated. They become unjust.

When institutions grow deaf, they lose touch with the realities of the people they are meant to serve. Decisions are made at a distance. Harm goes unrecognized. Inequities become embedded in policies and practices. Over time, what is broken can begin to feel normal.

This is why the prophets spoke so forcefully.

Amos does not address individuals alone. He confronts an entire system—a society that maintains religious rituals while neglecting justice. His words are direct and uncompromising: “Let justice roll down like waters.” The problem is not a lack of activity, but a failure to hear. The people have continued their practices, but they have stopped listening—to God and to those suffering within their midst.

This is the danger of institutional deafness.

Systems can continue to function, even to appear successful, while failing in their most important responsibilities. They can maintain structure without justice, order without compassion, and activity without accountability.

In such cases, listening becomes more than a value—it becomes a corrective.

Healthy institutions cultivate practices of listening.

They create real opportunities for participation, not just symbolic ones.They invite feedback from those most affected by their decisions, not only from those in positions of influence.They build structures of accountability that ensure concerns are not only heard, but addressed.

This kind of listening requires intention. It does not happen automatically.

Institutions, like individuals, face internal pressures that make listening difficult. There is a desire to protect reputation, to maintain control, or to avoid disruption. Feedback can feel threatening, especially when it exposes weaknesses or failures.

As a result, institutions may engage in what appears to be listening without actually changing.

But listening that does not lead to response is not true listening.It is performance.

Real listening involves a willingness to be shaped by what is heard. It requires openness to change, even when that change is difficult or costly.

When institutions listen well, something different becomes possible.

Trust begins to grow.Decisions become more grounded in lived reality.Communities feel seen and valued.And justice begins to take shape—not just in individual actions, but in the structures that govern shared life.

This is what Amos envisions: justice that flows, not as an isolated act, but as an ongoing reality—like water that moves continuously through the life of the community.

But this kind of justice does not emerge by accident.

It is sustained by systems that remain attentive—systems that continue to hear, to respond, and to adapt.

The Sh’ma calls communities to this kind of attentiveness. It reminds us that hearing is not a one-time act, but an ongoing discipline. It shapes not only personal faith, but collective life.

When institutions learn to listen, they become instruments of justice.

When they refuse to listen, they risk becoming obstacles to it.

To build a just society requires more than individuals who care.It requires systems that hear.

Reflection QuestionsHow can institutions create genuine cultures of listening rather than symbolic ones?Why is feedback often difficult for organizations to receive and act upon?Where have you seen institutions fail to listen—and what were the consequences?What changes when institutions become more attentive to those they serve?

PrayerGod of justice and wisdom,teach our communities to listen.Help our institutions remain open to truth,especially when it challenges us to change.Give us the courage to hear deeplyand the integrity to respond faithfully.May our shared life reflect compassion, fairness, and justice.Amen.


© The Times of Israel (Blogs)