The bill now before the Knesset that would elevate Torah study into Basic Law and effectively treat it as a substitute for traditional sherut leumi or military service is being sold as a victory for Jewish values. It is not. It is a betrayal of them. There are many arguments against this legislation. There are legal arguments, economic arguments, security arguments, and political arguments. But this week’s Torah reading, Matot–Masei offers a simpler and more devastating one.

“Shall your brothers go to war while you stay here?” (Numbers 32:6).

“Shall your brothers go to war while you stay here?” (Numbers 32:6).

When the tribes of Reuven and Gad ask to settle east of the Jordan rather than cross into the land with the rest of Israel, Moses responds with a question that should ring through the Knesset chamber: “Shall your brothers go to war while you stay here?” (Numbers 32:6).

That is not only a rebuke to two tribes in the wilderness. It is one of the Torah’s clearest statements about shared obligation. Reuven and Gad have legitimate needs. Their request is practical and rational. Moses does not deny that. What he refuses to accept is the idea that one group can secure its own future while others shoulder the burden of collective struggle.

That is why the proposed Basic Law: Torah Study is not only bad policy, it is bad Torah.

The bill, now moving through the Knesset after a first reading, would declare Torah study a foundational value of the State of Israel. That language might sound noble, but it is not appearing in a vacuum. It is appearing in the middle of Israel’s conscription crisis, after the High Court ordered the state to stop relying on blanket arrangements to exempt Haredi (Ultra Orthodox) yeshiva students from service, and in the middle of a war that has sent reservists back again and again to the front. Critics argue that the bill would entrench inequality in bearing the burden of service by giving legal cover to the claim that long-term yeshiva study should function........

© The Times of Israel (Blogs)