The videos of landslides in Kaghan Valley circulating on social media are a stark reminder that the monsoon has returned. Every year, it brings two familiar developments: dark clouds gathering over the horizon and official assurances that the country is prepared. Yet roads disappear beneath floodwaters, homes collapse, crops are destroyed, and millions of people are forced to rebuild lives they had only just begun to recover. The question is no longer whether floods will occur, but whether their consequences can be contained.

Floods are often described as natural disasters. In reality, only the rain is natural. Whether heavy rainfall becomes a humanitarian catastrophe depends largely on human decisions: where settlements are built, how rivers are managed, whether environmental regulations are enforced, and how effectively institutions prepare for foreseeable risks. Climate change has intensified flooding in Pakistan, but governance determines how destructive those floods become. The devastation of 2022 illustrated this distinction. More than 33 million people were affected, millions of homes were damaged or destroyed, agricultural land was inundated across the country, and economic losses exceeded US$30 billion. The disaster exposed structural weaknesses that can no longer be dismissed. Whether those lessons have translated into meaningful policy reform is far less certain.

The first lesson is that floods cannot be managed once the rain has begun. Disaster management begins long before the first drop falls, yet Pakistan's approach remains overwhelmingly reactive. Public debate still celebrates the speed of relief operations, the number of camps established, or the volume of aid distributed. These measures save lives and should never be underestimated, but they represent the final stage of........

© The Nation