Tackling Informal Economy With AI: From Invisible Workers To Identifiable Taxpayers—Part IV
Pakistan’s debate on widening the tax base has long confused counting people with collecting revenue. The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) announces the number of returns filed, celebrates additions to the Active Taxpayers List and imposes fresh restrictions on non-filers. Neither a return nor a computer-generated taxpayer number establishes that a person earns taxable income. A modern fiscal State should know the difference.
The first three parts of this series established the scale of informality, tested the revenue arithmetic and distinguished lawful livelihoods from organised criminal activity. The next question is institutional: how can Pakistan build a National Economic Registry (NER) that identifies genuine capacity to contribute without converting every citizen into a suspect?
The starting point must be statistical honesty. Pakistan Bureau of Statistics’ Labour Force Survey 2024–25 reported 83.1 million persons in the labour force under the updated international definition, against 85.6 million under the earlier definition. The difference arises principally from the revised treatment of subsistence producers. The same survey reports informal-sector employment at 72.5% of non-agricultural employment. Neither figure represents a ready-made pool of income-tax payers.[1]
Our ambition of identifying 30 million or more natural persons with taxable capacity is still a hypothesis to test, not a quota to impose. It should be validated against actual incomes, household dependency, business profits, assets, and exemptions. A daily wager may need social protection. A pensioner may owe nothing. An agricultural labourer is not the same as the owner of a profitable agricultural enterprise. An individual may earn from several sources without becoming several taxpayers.
Registration should be universal in reach, selective in taxation and respectful of the Constitution. A workable registry would begin with a verified identity, but not end there. It would record a person’s economic status—student, dependent, salaried employee, self-employed worker, employer, pensioner or person outside the labour force and link, where lawfully justified, to business registrations, declared income, property, vehicles and other economic indicators. Household relationships should help identify dependency, not create a presumption that one family member owns another’s income.
The registry must distinguish three layers. The first is basic identity and economic status, which can........
