1 Trending: Iran War Aside, Here Are Two Very Good Things Trump Is Doing Domestically

2 Trending: When California Republicans Run Against Democrats, They’re Running Against The Government

3 Trending: Trump’s Plan To Pull U.S. Troops From Europe Is Good For Everyone, And America Most Of All

4 Trending: This Covid Mandates Case Would Let Alito Prove The Left Doesn’t Care About Bodily Autonomy

Neil Gorsuch Is Wrong, America Isn’t A ‘Creedal Nation’

America is based on English culture and Christian civilization — a heritage that came before our civic creed and upon which our ideals rest.

Share Article on Facebook

Share Article on Twitter

Share Article on Truth Social

Share Article via Email

Supreme Court Justice Neil Gorsuch has done a series of interviews this week to promote his new children’s book about the Declaration of Independence and very clearly has a set of talking points, including a familiar liberal trope that’s no less false and incoherent for being familiar. America, says Gorsuch, is “creedal nation,” essentially a set of ideas that anyone can subscribe to and become an American. What’s more, Gorsuch claims America was founded as a creedal nation — a creed that enshrines the three ideals of equality, inalienable rights, and the right of self-government.

“What unites us is not a religion, it’s not a race, it’s a belief in those three ideals,” Gorsuch told NRO in a recent podcast. To Nick Gillespie of Reason he said, “Our nation is not founded on a religion. It’s not based on a common culture even, or heritage. It’s based on those ideas. We’re a creedal nation.”

For conservative-minded Americans of a certain age, repeating this mantra that we’re a creedal nation, not a blood-and-soil nation like bad old Europe, has become something of a reflex — a defensive posture meant to deflect charges of racism and xenophobia from the left.

But it’s obviously false. One way you can tell it’s false is that no one who espouses this America-as-creed idea would ever follow through on its implications. If we were really a creedal nation, and in order to be fully American you had to believe and live by a certain civic creed derived from the Declaration and the Constitution, enshrining those three ideals Gorsuch mentions, then millions of our fellow citizens today would not be considered true Americans — to say nothing of the millions of recent immigrants who have never even heard of the ideals supposedly at the heart of our creed.

If we’re a creedal nation, such people cannot be our countrymen. If we were serious about our creed, we would denaturalize and deport them. We would expel heretics and unbelievers as readily as........

© The Federalist