menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Founders, but Not Flawless: ‘The Great Contradiction’ Highlights Holes in American History

8 0
15.11.2026

Watch All Shows Victor Davis Hanson Tony Kinnett Daily Signal Signal Sitdown

Watch All Shows Victor Davis Hanson Tony Kinnett Daily Signal Signal Sitdown

Home – State Politics & News – Founders, but Not Flawless: ‘The Great Contradiction’ Highlights Holes in American History

Founders, but Not Flawless: ‘The Great Contradiction’ Highlights Holes in American History

In this 250th year of American independence, Americans are, rightly, celebrating the unique greatness of the Founders. These men fought and won a war against the world’s most powerful nation, gathered to write the Constitution that still governs the United States, and demonstrated courage and wisdom such as the world has never seen.

However, they were less than perfect.

In his previous 10 books, historian Joseph Ellis has written about the successes of the Founders. His work includes biographies of George Washington and Thomas Jefferson, as well as a history of the drafting of the Constitution.

His most recent work, however, takes a slightly different direction. “The Great Contradiction” tells about failures suffered by the Founders. That includes the error that, he writes, brought Virginia down from the pinnacle of American society and effectively made the commonwealth a political and economic backwater.

The two failures Ellis focuses on involve the treatment of those Native Americans living east of the Mississippi River at the time of the founding, as well as the treatment of slaves from 1776 until the death of Thomas Jefferson in 1826.

Ellis spends less time discussing policy toward natives because failure in that realm was probably inevitable. On Aug. 7, 1790, President George Washington,........

© The Daily Signal