menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Cape Town was the batting collapse we had to have. Now selectors must make changes

35 0
02.11.2026

Cape Town was the batting collapse we had to have. Now selectors must make changes

November 2, 2026 — 3:30pm

You have reached your maximum number of saved items.

Remove items from your saved list to add more.

No gift articles left

You've used all of your gift articles. 3 more will become available on the 1st of every month.

Paul Keating called the early-1990s economic downturn “the recession we had to have.” Similarly, Australia’s 111 in the fourth innings at Newlands was the collapse we had to have. Whether anyone learns from it is another matter.

I disagree with Pat Cummins that this is a very good side. It has been an excellent bowling side for a long time, but even the bowlers failed to trouble South Africa at crucial times. The Proteas batters had a plan in the second innings to let the short balls go and make the Australians bowl to them.

It was hard to discern any plan from our batters in their second innings in Cape Town. The Australian batting hasn’t carried its weight for some time, and a team holding a substantial first-innings lead doesn’t fold for 111 in the second innings if the batting is sound. The scoreboard doesn’t lie.

I take no pleasure in saying so. I’ve been a batsman, captain, selector and coach, and I’d rather be building than knocking.

I sat in a few dressing rooms after humbling experiences, but with straight shooters like Ian Chappell, Keith Stackpole and Rod Marsh, we were never allowed to pretend that we were just unlucky. It was shape up, or ship out.

Pat sees talent and good intent in that room, and he’s right. But to some extent a team operates in a bubble, and inside it every failure is bad luck. From outside, it looks different.

Start with the toss. Plenty thought bowling first on a good Cape Town pitch was a mistake, and I suspect Kagiso Rabada running through our top order was the biggest factor. Then we batted last on a surface that has........

© The Age