Get Ready for the Great Democratic Judicial Blockade
Sign up for Executive Dysfunction, a weekly newsletter that highlights one under-the-radar story about how Trump is changing the law—or how the law is pushing back—and keeps you posted on the latest from Slate’s Jurisprudence team.
Some earthquakes are felt with greatest force far from their epicenter. So it may be with Tuesday’s seismic election result. The new House and Senate lack the supermajorities needed to overcome vetoes, let alone impeach anyone. But the Democrats now have firm control over the Senate, and hence the confirmation process for federal judges for at least the next six years, and perhaps more. The vital question now is simple: Will there be any more judges?
Only days ago, it looked as if the conservative lock on the federal courts for a lifetime or more was secured beyond any possible doubt. Today, however, that vise grip on the power to set the basic terms of political life seems suddenly tenuous: The prospect of a Supreme Court that takes account of all the nation, and of all its heritage—as opposed to embodying the interests of a largely white, anti-immigrant, Christian nationalism—is suddenly in the cards again.
In part, this is a matter of simple numbers. Two members of the Supreme Court’s Republican supermajority—Samuel Alito (76) and Clarence Thomas (78)—will be 82 and 84, respectively, before there is even plausibly a Republican-controlled Senate. Alito had openly contemplated retiring, while Thomas had stoutly resisted the idea. But the choice is not always theirs. My old boss, Ruth Bader Ginsburg, passed just weeks before President Joe Biden won the White House. Her untimely death is a sharp reminder that openings on the court can happen despite the careful planning of the justices and their White House allies.
Were an opening to happen on the court after January but before the next presidential election, the Democrats........
