menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

No One Knows What Really Just Happened in Michigan

6 0
13.11.2026

Sign up for the Slatest to get the most insightful analysis, criticism, and advice out there, delivered to your inbox daily.

Abdul El-Sayed arrived to the Capitol on Monday as a senator-elect with the air of a rising political force. Since his win last week over Mike Rogers in Michigan, he’s been on a ubiquitous media tour, confronting issues like U.S. support for Israel and healthcare for all (he offered to name the bill “Trumpcare” if they got it done) with the same brashness he had during the campaign. He posed for beaming photos with other newly elected Democrats and posted a sly, widely shared shot outside his office with his new name plate. It was clear he was enjoying himself.

View this post on Instagram

It was all hard to reconcile with what I’d seen on the campaign trail barely even a week earlier in Michigan. Polls showed he held an advantage, but it often wasn’t obvious to me from the ground that he could win.

On Election Day, outside Burns Seventh-day Adventist Church in Detroit, a light conversation I had with three men near the entrance took an awkward turn. One had noticed a number of Arab voters, and he wasn’t happy about it. They were “trying to get their guy in there,” he said. Arab-owned corner stores and gas stations, he complained, sold alcohol, tobacco, and vapes that were poisoning the neighborhood. In the best case, an El-Sayed victory would win those business owners favors, the man thought. In the worst, some Arabs would be walking around with bombs strapped to their chests.

Then he looked me in eye and asked, “You’re not one of them, are you?” I told him I was. He didn’t take it back. “Well, that’s what they do in their country,” he said.

Those claims weren’t much worse than the ads I’d seen about El-Sayed on every television I came across. Republican advertisers spent $46 million on attacks invoking Shariah law, dual loyalties to foreign and domestic Muslim groups, terrorism, or 9/11. One ad used a woman in a niqab as a warning about what El-Sayed would bring to Michigan. Two days before the election, Haley Stevens, the Democrat he beat in the primary, accused him of supporting bigotry and endorsed Rogers. I couldn’t claim to be surprised by any of this, exactly—I was a teenager in the immediate post-9/11 years and knew how ugly it could get—but it was still stunning to see.

I first interviewed El-Sayed at his home last April, where he poured me an espresso shot using equipment that looked like it belonged in a laboratory. He reminded me of an older cousin. His Egyptianness was contagious. At one point, I sneezed. “Alhamdulillah,” I said. “Yarhamuk Allah,” he answered without missing a beat. It was the most ordinary exchange between two Muslims, but a remarkable one to have with someone running for the United States Senate.

Even then El-Sayed was confident, but he turned shaky when he reflected on his failed bid for Michigan governor in 2018. “It took me years to heal from that, because I felt like I let everyone down,” he told me then. “I don’t want to stumble. I don’t want to fall. I don’t want to dash anybody’s hopes.”

That helped explain how forcefully El-Sayed went after his critics, and why his swagger—which, to me, seemed a bit exaggerated at times, given how comes off in private—was so important to his new political persona and his supporters. Since Trump took power, Democrats I interviewed over the years talked about the need for a fighter, and a populist who could deliver on policies that polled well.

I understood it on that level. It all felt personal to me, too. How could it not? When people were attacking our ethnicity and religion? I loved watching him punch back, but I also caught myself worrying about how his anger would be perceived. I knew how easily a Muslim man defending himself could be made to look like the dangerous fanatic his opponents wanted people to see. I hated that I was even making that calculation.

Maybe that was part of what I saw changing in front me. In New York, Zohran Mamdani had won without apologizing for being Muslim or abandoning........

© Slate