The Other Side of Medical Gaslighting
Take our Gaslighting Test
Find a therapist who understands manipulative behavior
Epistemic injustice in medicine has two sides: patient deficit and doctor excess.
Doctors’ epistemic privilege actively reshapes how they perceive patients.
Most medical dismissal is not based on bad intentions, but structural imbalance.
Most accounts of medical gaslighting follow the same arc: A patient presents with symptoms, they are dismissed, told it is stress, told the tests are normal, told to come back if things get worse. They leave without answers, sometimes wondering whether they imagined the whole thing. Eventually, perhaps years later, a diagnosis arrives that confirms what they had been saying all along.
That experience is well documented. Women, people of colour, and patients with conditions that lack clear biomarkers can face difficulties being believed, and the consequences of being dismissed can be serious.
But there is another person in the story who rarely gets examined: the doctor who did the dismissing.
A paper published this month in Philosophical Psychology argues that this is an important omission. Lucienne Spencer suggests that when we talk about epistemic injustice in medicine, we tend to focus on the person whose experience and knowledge is being discounted. We pay much less attention to what happens to the person whose knowledge is routinely given more weight (Spencer, 2026).
How Doctors Exercise Epistemic Privilege
Spencer describes this unequal distribution of credibility as epistemic privilege. Doctors enter clinical encounters with an authority that patients do not have. They have the training, the........
