Take our Ambition Test

Find a therapist near me

Harmonious passion and obsessive passion look identical from the outside, but are very different long-term.

Harmonious passion is driven by positive reinforcement—moving toward something genuinely loved.

Obsessive passion is driven by running away from fear of failure or worthlessness.

Over time, obsessive passion often leads to burnout and worse performance under pressure.

Tom Brady knows a thing or two (or seven) about winning. He’s the winningest quarterback of all time and has literally won more NFL Super Bowl rings than any other team in the history of the game.

So when he recently wrote a newsletter piece on how to be great and present, I was quick to read it. And something in his newsletter certainly stuck with me, but in a way that made me question and contradict a basic point.

Brady was reflecting on a framework offered by podcaster Chris Williamson for the amount of psychological effort it takes to get things done. The idea was simple: Discipline takes the most effort, motivation a little less, and obsession practically none, because you’re so consumed that doing the thing doesn’t feel like effort at all.

Brady built on this beautifully. He let us know that, since being a kid, his obsession was with throwing the perfect spiral. That obsession drove his motivation to continue practicing, eventually playing football at the highest level, which drove the discipline of his well-known practice and training work that produced seven Super Bowl wins.

Obsession at the root of the cascade. The rest followed.

It’s a compelling frame. And it’s partially right.

But I’ve been studying habits and motivation for the last 20 years, and here’s what the research actually says, which is more nuanced and more useful than the hustle culture version of this story: First, discipline creates habits, which substantially reduce the psychological effort required to do anything (good or bad). But importantly, not all obsession is created equal—and the type of fire you’re burning matters more than how hot it burns.

Brady may indeed have been obsessed, but maybe he should have focused on being passionate about that perfect spiral.

To understand why, we need to go back to the research.

Two Kinds of “Can’t Not Do This"

In 2003, psychologist Robert Vallerand introduced a framework that has now been confirmed across 94 studies. He calls it the Dualistic Model of Passion, and it identifies two fundamentally different versions of the “I can’t not do this”........

© Psychology Today