The government's failure to make the case for refugees
Australia’s migration debate has become consumed by numbers, borders and fear, while failures in temporary migration management and the treatment of Palestinians expose deeper questions of multiculturalism and humanitarian responsibility.
Poorly managed migration and a humanitarian failure.
Instead of migration being about economics or humanitarian concerns, Pauline Hanson turns it into a culture war about identity and fear.
The problem is also not so much about ‘migration’, but failure to properly manage temporary residents.
For decades we have been told that migration is too high. Blaming the outsider, the stranger, the migrant is as old as human history itself, and blaming migrants for housing unaffordability protects the real culprits. Australia’s housing crisis is produced by zoning failures, negative gearing and capital gains tax concessions, neglect of public housing construction for decades and the financialisation of residential property that turned the family home into a shelter for a speculative asset class.
We are an immigration nation. We can be proud of what we have achieved. We have done it better than any other country. The government should stop being so negative and defensive about it.
We see that pride in our strong support for multiculturalism. Critics talk about migration in the abstract, but through encounters with the Lebanese shopkeeper, the Filipino nurse or the Muslim doctor we learn that our hostility and scepticism is misplaced. Our health and care services would collapse without migrants.
Tony Burke and his Department of Home Affairs have let us down. The department is focused on security and border control, not migration. That same neglect is reflected in the handling of multiculturalism. The minister for........
