menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Private health insurance costs taxpayers $13 billion a year. What for?

92 0
02.09.2026

Taxpayers spend about $13 billion a year supporting private health insurance, yet there is little evidence it relieves pressure on public hospitals or delivers fair value.

It favours the wealthy, is inefficient and has not taken the pressure off public hospitals. It takes us down the disastrous road of US health. It’s a con.

In the recent budget, Private Health Insurance (PHI) benefits for some older Australians were scheduled to be marginally reduced. It will remove the age-based bonus which is desirable considering the benefits enjoyed by most senior Australians. But Private Healthcare Australia (PHA), complained as usual and produced some dubious modelling.

Professor Yuting Zhang and colleagues commented in The Conversation, “this reform won’t cause a mass exodus from PHI and definitely won’t overwhelm public hospitals as some states predict”.

A recent study by health economists at the University of Melbourne found that the government changes will have little impact on PHI participation. They commented that PHI uptake is driven by health needs and habits, with many maintaining insurance because they have always had it.

They also added that there is little evidence that subsidising PHI materially relieves pressure on public hospitals, since both draw on the same clinical workforce, not every private procedure would otherwise occur in a public hospital, and PHI generally does not cover emergency department attendance.

It is time to carefully bring this taxpayer subsidy to an end. This minor scale-back of the PHI subsidy should be followed by a steady phasing out entirely of the subsidy. The billions spent annually could be better spent on mental health, the funding of specialist services in public hospitals to counter very high fees by some private specialists, and the inclusion of dental in Medicare.

If Australians want PHI, they should pay for it and not expect taxpayers to subsidise them. There is a universal system available to all. It’s called Medicare.

Public discussion about PHI often refers only to the direct government rebate of $7.9 billion per annum. But there........

© Pearls and Irritations