menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Kostakidis case strikes a blow for free speech

72 0
14.09.2026

The case against Mary Kostakidis has been discontinued without any finding that she breached the Racial Discrimination Act, ending a two-year legal battle over political expression and criticism of Israel.

‘Free speech, journalism and democracy in a time of genocide’

That was the heading of an article by Mary Kostakidis on Pearls and Irritations on 23 October 2024.

After a two-year legal battle designed to silence a journalist for criticising Israel’s genocide in Gaza, the case against Mary Kostakidis by Zionist Federation of Australia chief executive Alan Cassuto has been discontinued, with both parties bearing their own costs. It is a victory for her and every Australian who values freedom of political expression.

Last week’s development means there is no finding that Mary breached the Racial Discrimination Act. No apology has been ordered. No costs were awarded against her. Cassuto issued a statement, unnecessarily taking shots at Kostakidis and refusing to acknowledge the win for freedom of speech – comments to cover his defeat.

Mary Kostakidis, on the other hand, said: “This is a win for every Australian who values our democratic right to freedom of political expression. Zionist zealotry has had to beat a retreat from what was going to be a highly damaging trial. The purpose of journalism is to get to the truth – fearlessly – and to hold power to account. This is a win for press freedom, which has prevailed.”

The complaint originated from social media posts in which Mary shared a speech by Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah with a comment pointing to the threat of escalation in violence that violence begets. Unfortunately, violence did beget violence. On 27 September 2024, shortly after the social media posts, Hassan Nasrallah was assassinated in an Israeli airstrike in Beirut.

On P&I in October........

© Pearls and Irritations