Government must act to fix broken health system
Runaway specialist fees and years-long public waiting lists demand immediate action. Government has the power, says John Menadue, it just needs to deploy it.
In the short term some important reforms can be made with almost no increase in government spending. Longer term improvements will require additional funding. We need to raise taxes to do that.
Medical specialist fees have been out of control for years. Those who cannot pay them join public hospital queues that can run to years.
The bulk-billing rate for GPs is about 84 per cent. For specialists it is about 28 per cent. Specialists earn about twice as much as GPs. Taxation statistics for 2022/23 show that four of the top five occupations by taxable income in Australia were medical specialists: surgeons, anaesthetists, internal medicine specialists and psychiatrists.
It is a system without guard rails. The average out-of-pocket cost of a non-bulk-billed specialist consultation rose from $46 in 2009/10 to $126 in 2024/25. Some psychiatrists and surgeons charge up to $1,000 upfront, and one in two patients do not know the fee before the first appointment. Knee replacement fees doubled in six years, from $560 to $1,080. The median out-of-pocket cost of a hip replacement was $1,240, with one patient in ten paying more than $5,500. I have seen quotes of $2,000 and $2,500 per eye for cataract surgery.
Private health insurance has made it worse. When insurers introduced gap cover, many specialists dramatically increased their fees. The $13 billion taxpayer subsidy to private health insurance is directly responsible for some of that fee gouging.
In a 2025 report the Grattan Institute found that about 1.9 million Australians delay or skip getting the care they need because of waiting lists. People living in the poorest parts of Australia receive about one-third fewer specialist services than people in the wealthiest areas. The........
