menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

A Blueprint of Dysfunction: Europe's Reaction to Its Geopolitical Shake-up, Reflex or Deeply Rooted Identity? Part 1

46 0
latest

A Blueprint of Dysfunction: Europe’s Reaction to Its Geopolitical Shake-up, Reflex or Deeply Rooted Identity? Part 1

What appears to be an abrupt change of attitude is actually a long-standing reflex of a continent which has never properly come to grips with how they have gained their wealth, power and memory.

The Reckoning That Wasn’t: Colonialist Amnesia, Panics and the Two Europes

Any capital in Europe this autumn will have a similar feeling of nervousness. Germany’s AfD have just secured 43.8% in State elections. Washington is negotiating Ukraine’s future. A French court has allowed Marine Le Pen to run for the Élysée and the Mediterranean has once again become a site of death with the presence of a coastguard. This has been described by commentators as a ‘polycrisis’, an overly technical term and not really explaining anything.

I would argue, however, that what appears to be an abrupt change of attitude is actually a long-standing reflex of a continent which has never properly come to grips with how they have gained their wealth, power and memory. The first part of this article discusses the colonial past and migration panic. The second part looks at the rise of the right and the curious absence of the left. The third part considers Europe’s Nazi legacy including Ukraine, and how Europe is losing its geopolitical power. Every example below is from a different country.

Apologies Aren’t Reckonings

Europeans are very good at holding ceremonies. The Netherlands apologised in December 2022. Belgium’s king has expressed ‘deepest regrets’ for Congo. The Belgian state in June 2022 returned the last remnant of Patrice Lumumba, a gold capped tooth, to his family. In December 2022, the Dutch Prime Minister apologised and created a fund of €200 million, clearly stating descendants would not receive compensation. Germany and Namibia declared a joint statement on the genocide of the Herero and Nama people in 2021, however only ‘from today’s perspective’. Around €1.1 billion will go to the countries over thirty years. Representatives of the Herero and Nama people, who were excluded from the negotiations, state this is not reparations but development aid. In 2013, Britain paid 19.9 million to 5,228 Kenyans who were tortured during the Mau Mau uprising. It stated it ‘sincerely regrets’ the abuse, however denied legal responsibility.

Note how they use the words ‘regrets’, ‘expressed regrets’ and ‘declared’ — no-one uses the word owe.

France is the best example. In 2005, parliament passed legislation to teach students about the ‘positive role’ of colonisation abroad. However, this was heavily protested by historians and the clause was removed the following year. A decade later, a candidate named Emmanuel Macron stated that colonisation was a ‘crime against humanity’ in Algiers, and received heavy backlash from within his own country. The Algerian War of Independence, involving torture and hundreds........

© New Eastern Outlook