Ask what causes Pakistan’s food insecurity and the instinctive answer is scarcity: not enough land, not enough water, not enough grain. The instinct is wrong, and the contrast with the Gulf makes that clear. Every Gulf state that solved its food security problem started from almost nothing: minimal arable land, near-zero fresh water, and import dependence above 80 percent. Pakistan has the Indus basin, one of the largest irrigation systems on earth, and farmland the desert economies of the Gulf never had. In most staples, it is already a net food producer. Yet millions of Pakistanis remain in crisis-level food insecurity or worse, a situation formally flagged since 2019, while three desert economies with a fraction of Pakistan’s natural advantages have moved through an arc the Gulf itself describes simply: importers became producers, and producers became exporters.

That is not a story about geography. It is a story about what happens after the harvest.

Qatar moved fastest. Facing a sudden disruption to its food supply in 2017, it reached 30 percent self-sufficiency in dairy within six months and full self-sufficiency by 2019, eventually exporting to neighboring markets. It took two years, backed by sovereign capital that could move immediately and at scale. Pakistan cannot match that speed, and does not need to. Its problem was never a shortage of dairy cows.

Saudi Arabia’s path is more instructive. Importing roughly 80 percent of its food, Riyadh spent about seven years under Vision 2030 building toward........

© Arab News Pakistan