Opinion National Interest PoV 50-Word Edit

ThePrint On Camera Videos In Pictures

Society & Culture Around Town Book Excerpts Vigyapanti The Dating Story

More Judiciary Education YourTurn Work With Us Campus Voice

Opinion National Interest PoV 50-Word Edit

ThePrint On Camera Videos In Pictures

Society & Culture Around Town Book Excerpts Vigyapanti The Dating Story

More Judiciary Education YourTurn Work With Us Campus Voice

Mock the Indian uncle. Don’t turn him into a glib theory of India

The problem with a recent Economist article, ‘India’s republic of uncles’, is the old habit of mistaking a clever metropolitan caricature for civilisational diagnosis.

The Indian uncle is often mocked, and not without reason. He has opinions about your degree, your salary, your marriage, your phone, your posture and possibly your digestion. His advisory kit is familiar: beta, listen; work harder; keep the phone away; and yes, five soaked almonds in the morning. He treats the absence of consent as a small procedural irregularity.

So yes, the joke lands. One recent instance is The Economist’s “India’s republic of uncles”, a witty piece on the “cockroach” meme and India’s supposedly gerontocratic instincts, down to the soaked almonds. It is sharp. It is funny. It is also glib. The problem is not who writes about India, but the old habit of mistaking a clever metropolitan caricature for civilisational diagnosis.

Now, the uncle can survive mockery. What is less defensible is turning him into an all-purpose explanation for India. Judicial arrogance, exam failures, phone restrictions, corporate sermons, political authority and youth frustration are all placed under one convenient heading: uncle.

Also Read: From e-rickshaw pranks to denying lifts in the RWA—Indians’ joke is always on the poor

Good satire, lazy sociology

What is mocked as “uncle culture” is often closer to the moral common sense of the average Indian. A large Pew survey found that nearly nine in ten Indians — 88 per cent — consider respecting elders very important to being “truly Indian”, with little variation by religion, region, caste or age. Pew also found that India’s major religious communities broadly share this respect-for-elders ethic as part of religious and cultural life.

That does not make every elder wise, but it does mean that the uncle is not an exotic fossil left behind by modernity. He is part of India’s moral grammar: advice, intergenerational respect, restraint, family obligation, thrift, duty and accumulated experience. These values can become suffocating. But they are not automatically stupid merely because they are........

© ThePrint