First Quad Leaders' Summit Under Trump Softens Criticism of China's Maritime Actions, Flags Economic ‘Coercion’
New Delhi: After a gap of over two years, leaders of the four Quad countries finally met on Tuesday (November 17), but the summit saw noticeably less emphasis on criticising China’s maritime actions in the Indo-Pacific, even as it flagged concerns over “economic coercion”.
India was supposed to host the leaders’ summit in 2025, but the annual pow-wow had fallen by the wayside under the second Donald Trump administration until now. Although the foreign ministers continued to meet, the leaders had not convened since 2024, breaking a run of annual summits that began in 2021.
Their meeting in Manila was also the first time the four leaders had gathered in a non-Quad member country. There was no mention of any future leaders’ meeting for next year by any leader or in a diplomatic document.
Trump arrived in Manila on the final day of the ASEAN summit and went straight into a Quad leaders’ meeting at the Solaire Resort. Lasting approximately 90 minutes, the meeting between the leaders of India, Australia, the United States and Japan began with a joint photo session and opening remarks to the media.
However, the Quad meeting was taking place amid considerable anticipation over the first-ever trilateral summit between Trump, Russian President Vladimir Putin and Chinese President Xi Jinping, scheduled for Wednesday in China. The upcoming meeting also dominated the questions during the photo session, with Trump fielding queries largely about China, the Nvidia controversy and the trilateral summit, while the other three leaders stood silently beside him.
A quieter line on China’s maritime actions
Two years ago, the Wilmington Declaration as per the norm didn’t name China, but it was rather more explicit than usual in criticising actions taken by Beijing in the disputed waters of the Indo-Pacific.
In 2024, the declaration said the Quad leaders were “seriously concerned about the situation in the East and South China Seas”. It specifically criticised the “militarisation of disputed features” and “coercive and intimidating manoeuvres” in the South China Sea, and condemned the “dangerous use of coast guard and maritime militia vessels”. The declaration also endorsed the 2016 Arbitral Award on the South China Sea, describing it as a “significant milestone” and the basis for peacefully resolving disputes between the parties.
The November 17 joint press release dropped all these specific references. The absence of the 2016 Arbitral Award was especially notable given that the summit was being held in the Philippines, where tensions with Beijing over the........
